The Hidden Cost of the Cloud: Bandwidth Charges

Allan Leinwand
Gigaom.com

July 17, 2009 | 5:15 PM PT

http://gigaom.com/2009/07/17/the-hidden-cost-of-the-cloud-bandwidth-charges/#more-59702


Microsoft is spending hundreds of millions of dollars to build out its 
next generation of data centers to host its cloud computing offering, 
Windows Azure Platform. While the company is clearly innovative in its 
data center designs and plans, the true reason behind its push toward 
the cloud may be its ability to turn a commodity product –- bandwidth –- 
into high gross profits. A quick analysis that we here at Panorama 
Capital did shows that the commodity business of selling the transfer of 
bytes may be one of the most profitable parts of running a cloud service.

Azure charges 10 cents for the bandwidth to upload and 15 cents to 
download a gigabyte of data. The disparity in pricing, I believe, is 
meant to encourage Microsoft developers to move lots of applications and 
associated data into Azure and then have lots of users access the 
applications from the same platform.

Let’s assume that a customer of Azure develops an application that 
downloads 10 gigabytes of traffic per day, 20 business days a month. 
That means the application downloads a total of 200 gigabytes of traffic 
in a month (and to make the point, let’s assume that the upload traffic 
is minimal). Azure charges the customer $30 per month for this bandwidth 
use (200 gigabytes times 15 cents per gigabyte), which seems like a 
small amount to pay.

If the customer’s application is only sending data and consuming 
bandwidth 12 hours a day –- all of its users are in North America — 
during 20 business days, that means that the customer is effectively 
using 1.85 megabits per second of bandwidth during the month (200 
gigabytes per month divided by the sum of 20 days times 12 hours in a 
day times 60 minutes an hour times 60 seconds per minute). Put another 
way, the customer’s $30 per month equates to a bandwidth charge of 
$16.20 per megabit ($30 divided by 1.85 megabits per second).

Cloud service providers buy a lot of bandwidth to provide access to the 
Internet. My market research (albeit not exhaustive) puts the current 
price per megabit of bandwidth for a large cloud provider at around $8. 
That means that for the 1.85 megabits per second that the customer uses, 
Azure effectively pays $14.81 to its bandwidth provider and keeps 
$15.91, or 51 percent gross profit — not a bad profit margin on a 
commodity business like bandwidth. To be fair, other cloud service 
providers, like Amazon and Rackspace, charge similar or higher bandwidth 
fees and likely make similar gross profits.

While this example is for a fairly limited charge to the customer of 
Azure, if a customer were to build an application on Azure that 
generates a lot of bandwidth, then the costs and profits to Microsoft 
get substantial. For an application that downloads 200 gigabytes per 
month, the costs are $600 for bandwidth for about 37 megabits per second 
of usage (again assuming the application only consumes bandwidth half of 
the day for 20 business days a month). Of that $600, Microsoft pays its 
service provider $296.30 and keeps $303.70 of gross profit.

And the model scales linearly –- if Microsoft can build up Azure to 
cumulatively charge for all customers’ applications sending 100,000 
gigabytes of data a day, it will reap approximately $151,000 in daily 
gross profit off bandwidth. That would equate to a lot of copies of 
Microsoft Windows sold daily without any packaged software developers on 
staff required. With these gross profit margins, one can easily 
understand why Microsoft is building thousands of megabits of bandwidth 
to serve data from Azure applications.

So if you’re using a cloud customer and your application will send a lot 
of data from the cloud, our analysis indicates that once you’re sending 
over 50 gigabytes of data daily (or a terabyte a month costing you $150 
on Azure, for example), it may make sense to leave the cloud and buy 
your own bandwidth to the Internet –- you’ll probably save 50 percent of 
your monthly bandwidth charges. The trick will be moving your 
application from the cloud to your own infrastructure and dedicated 
bandwidth and then finding the expertise to manage this environment. 
Cloud service providers are counting on that being a difficult trick to 
perform.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to