Senate antitrust leader fears Comcast will kneecap Hulu

By Nate Anderson
Ars Technica

May 28, 2010

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2010/05/senate-antitrust-leader-fears-comcast-will-kneecap-hulu.ars


As a child growing up in Wisconsin, visits to the department store 
Kohl's were a yearly rite of passage, providing a pair of back-to-school 
pants at 50 percent off. My youthful self—squirming in discomfort every 
time mom called back into the changing room, "How do those fit in the 
crotch?"—could never have predicted that one day, decades in the future, 
the owner of that store would sit in Congress... and try to keep Comcast 
away from Hulu in an effort to defend Internet delivery of shows like Lost.

Wisconsin senator Herb Kohl has moved on up from his days as discount 
department store magnate, and he now chairs the Senate Subcommittee on 
Antitrust, Competition Policy, and Consumer Rights. In that role, he has 
taken a natural interest in the proposed Comcast/NBC buyout. Yesterday, 
Kohl outlined his own preferred conditions on such a deal in a letter to 
the FCC and the Department of Justice, both of which are reviewing the deal.

What does Kohl want? Comcast to stay out of Hulu after any purchase. 
When does he want it? Within a year.
Out of Hulu for good

Kohl's concern is that "over-the-top" Internet-delivered video poses a 
serious challenge to the existing business model of a cable company like 
Comcast. If Comcast acquires NBC and takes over NBC's 32 percent stake 
in Hulu, the company might be tempted to cripple the service, or weigh 
it down with enough conditions to make sure people stick with expensive, 
separate cable subscriptions. Kohl writes:

" Millions of consumers have begun to utilize Internet web sites such as 
Hulu to view full-length programming that has traditionally been shown 
on cable and broadcast television."

"And, numerous companies are experimenting with new business models for 
delivering content directly to consumers over high speed internet 
connections—including television and blue-ray disc manufacturers, Apple 
TV, Roku, Boxee, and Zillion TV, to give a few examples. Industry 
reports have estimated that 800,000 households have even dropped their 
traditional MVPD [multichannel TV] subscriptions, preferring to view 
video content over the Internet (often referred to as "cord-cutters"). 
It is clear that video over the Internet has the real potential to 
become a strong competitive alternative to traditional MVPD providers 
and offer consumers new choices to obtain video programming without 
expensive MVPD subscriptions."

Herb Kohl (or, most likely, a staffer) knows about Boxee! And Roku! And 
he's interested in Internet video! This is such terrific stuff that 
we'll forgive him for the "blue-ray" comment.

"After the acquisition, Comcast will have the incentive to exercise its 
influence as a part owner of Hulu to ensure it does not become a 
competitive threat to Comcast's cable television services," the letter 
continues. "If Comcast exercised such a strategy, it could effectively 
starve these new, emerging Internet distributors of the content they 
need to compete. Comcast has already begun to roll out its 'TV 
Everywhere' model of distribution, under which Comcast subscribers can 
have full access to their cable programming wherever they are. While 
this business model unquestionably offers benefits to consumers, it also 
could potentially harm competition should it become the exclusive manner 
in which programmers deliver their content over the Internet."

In Kohl's view, Comcast should be forced to divest NBC's stake in Hulu 
within one year of the acquisition. In addition, he wants "a requirement 
that Comcast not seek to prevent or coerce programmers from keeping 
their content off Internet web sites or Internet distributors as a 
condition of carriage on Comcast."

Of course, a cable ISP has all sorts of ways to obtain a similar 
outcome. One could simply slap tiny data caps on the "Internet access" 
side of the business, high enough to do Web surfing but low enough to 
prevent large-scale video viewing. (To its credit, Comcast's published 
caps have been a relatively generous 250GB per month.) One could 
throttle video sites like Hulu. (Comcast's recent win in court against 
the FCC has effectively abolished the agency's existing claims to net 
neutrality oversight.)

Kohl's requests bring political pressure on the agencies to impose these 
kinds of conditions, but Kohl has no direct authority over the deal.

Comcast sent over a statement about the letter, one expecting "that any 
conditions will not unduly burden either Comcast or NBCU’s businesses."

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to