May 28, 2010

NBC Says 'No' to iPad, Wants People to Pay

By SARAH PEREZ
ReadWriteWeb.com

http://www.nytimes.com/external/readwriteweb/2010/05/28/28readwriteweb-nbc-says-no-to-ipad-wants-people-to-pay-20042.html?pagewanted=print


NBC isn't hopping on the iPad bandwagon, according to recent reports. 
The media giant known for popular shows like "The Office" and "30 Rock" 
reportedly told Apple it won't be making any of its online shows 
iPad-compatible anytime soon. And it's not alone. Sources cited by The 
New York Post's Claire Atkinson say that Time Warner and several other 
"large media companies" are forgoing what they claim is an expensive 
reformatting of their video libraries.

But is conversion expense the real reason why some media companies are 
eschewing the Apple iPad craze? Or is the fact that the ad dollars just 
aren't there yet to make it worth their while?

That some media companies aren't "iPad-ready" isn't new information by 
any means, but the fact that it's being rehashed, re-reported and 
re-analyzed is notable, especially following Google's newfound 
partnership with Adobe, whose Flash plugin stills powers much of the 
video on the Web today.

With support for Flash in both the upcoming Google TV platform, as well 
as in Google's Android mobile operating system (an OS that's now 
outselling Apple's iPhone), Google is making it clear that for the time 
being, the Web still needs Flash. And media companies like NBC and Time 
Warner are along for the ride. Why convert videos for the iPad when 
Android may dominate? Why waste time on "iDevice" support when ad 
dollars associated with streaming media barely impact the bottom line?

These are the very questions major media companies are considering as we 
speak.

Streaming Ads Don't Pay

Some TV and video is available for free on the iPad today, but it's 
still more limited that what you would find on the Web in general. ABC 
has an iPad app, but that's not surprising considering that the 
Disney-owned property has Jobs as its largest shareholder. CBS has an 
iPad-friendly site, but only a few shows are available, and media-filled 
sites like CNN, Fox News, ESPN.com and others offer varying degrees of 
iPad-readiness.

But NBC won't be following these early adopters, it appears.

There's a very telling quote about this issue from NBC Universal's 
president and CEO, Jeff Zucker, that he delivered in January. Speaking 
about tech advances and the iPad in particular, he said, "We believe in 
ubiquitous distribution of our content and the fact is consumers want to 
engage with our content wherever they are... As long as we get paid for 
that content, we don't really care where it's displayed or where it's used."

"Get paid," he said. Streaming video sites, even the NBC Universal 
creation Hulu.com, have been struggling to make that a reality. Although 
Hulu finally reached profitability this year, the numbers aren't 
anywhere near what traditional TV advertising brings in. Hulu's revenue 
topped $100 million in 2009, according to Hulu chief Jason Kilar. To put 
that in perspective, a 30-second national broadcast TV commercial maybe 
makes around $300,00-$500,000 these days.

Too Expensive to Convert?

But is there any truth to the claims that conversion is too expensive? 
Open-Web zealots will tell you that's a bunch of "FUD" - conversion 
costs are minimal and there are plenty of solutions out there for 
ditching Flash and moving to HTML5, the upcoming Web standard that 
supports plugin-free video viewing.

In reality, while HTML5-enabled video streams are possible today, large 
media publishers are still waiting for video platform providers to catch 
up to the capabilities Adobe's Flash currently offers, including rich 
analytics, advertising and engagement tracking, and more.

That's just around the corner, though.

For example, video platform provider Brightcove will be on par with 
Flash by year-end, according to its published roadmap. However, the 
expense of conversion is not necessarily as trivial as Apple CEO Steve 
Jobs has made it seem. The truth, said Brightcove CEO Jeremy Allaire, is 
that "it depends." As he told us earlier, publishers that use homegrown 
video solutions will have more expenses associated with the creation of 
HTML5 websites. But for customers using platform solutions (like his, of 
course), the transition is much easier. But Flash and HTML5 will 
co-exist for years, he said. It's not a matter of ditching one for the 
other. That means companies offering an iPad-compatible website must 
maintain it separately and there is some cost involved with that, 
minimal as it may be.

But Conversion Cost Isn't the Problem Here: NBC & Others Just Want to 
Make Money

Last month, The New York Times reported that NBC execs were showing off 
a mock-up of an iPad/iPhone-compatible mobile website that offered full 
episodes of popular shows, ready for streaming. At the last minute, 
however, the company decided to block iPad viewing of these shows. At 
present, only clips and the short-form "webisodes" play on the iPhone or 
iPad.

The fact that NBC had already gone so far as to build a mock-up of an 
iPad-friendly site makes the whole "it's too expensive" argument 
questionable, at least in this case.

So let's get real about this. NBC isn't a great network these days. In 
fact, it hasn't been "must-see TV" since "Friends" or maybe even the 
"Seinfeld" era. Olympics coverage notwithstanding, the network trailed 
others during the past season, losing out to Fox and CBS, both of whom 
were riding high on the return of the sitcom and reality programming.

Does NBC want to give away its best content for free right now? No. If 
anyone is bothering to tune into NBC at all, they had better be paying 
for it, thinks the network, either via their eyeballs glued to the TV 
screen, via a paid-for iTunes download or perhaps soon, via a 
subscription to the long-rumored, but still unrealized Hulu iPad 
application.

Curse, NBC, Time Warner and other iPad holdouts if you want for limiting 
the fun you can have with your new slate computer. But for them, the 
iPad isn't pushing these companies toward the quick adoption of 
HTML5-powered video - it's pushing them to figure out a business model 
for making video pay.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to