MAY 28, 2010

Polaroid's Clunky Comeback

By MARY PILON
Wall Street Journal

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704596504575272481059479178.html?mod=WSJ_Tech_RIGHTTopCarousel


Imagine if, after years of relishing your iPod, someone plopped a 
Walkman in your hand.

That's how I've felt testing the Polaroid 300, the new instant camera 
from Polaroid Corp. What ensued was a digital existential crisis.

For years, Polaroid made its name by offering football-sized cameras 
that went well with fanny packs and and spat out square snapshots that 
developed instantly (or, at least, what passed for instant back then).

Ironically, Polaroid became a victim of instant gratification, filing 
for bankruptcy in 2008 as analog instant photography had become 
irrelevant in the digital age. The cult of Polaroidians mourned – 
online, ironically enough -- and visual and written eulogies, some 
angry, poured in when the company announced it would no longer produce 
its iconic square film.

Polaroid fans weren't left empty-handed for long: late last year, 
Fujifilm launched its own Polaroid-esque camera, the Fujifilm Instax 
Mini 7. Now, Polaroid has partnered with Fujifilm to rebrand that camera 
(with a few design tweaks) as a genuine Polaroid, with a new, 
business-card size version of the company's signature film, which can be 
used interchangeably with the Instax Mini. (A Dutch group called the 
Impossible Project has separately begun manufacturing film that will 
work with old Polaroid cameras).

The Polaroid 300 retails for $89.99 and comes in red, blue or black. 
It's currently available online and at Bloomingdale's and J & R stores, 
for pre-order on Polaroid.com and will roll out to national retailers in 
July.

This camera is smaller than its grandparents, but larger than today's 
svelte digital counterparts. It's conspicuously chunky and looks 
straight-up Fisher-Price. It's about as durable as a kid camera, too, 
surviving a week in my bag and two stumbles down concrete stairs with 
only minor scratching.

The camera is simple enough for a kid to use too: you yank out the lens 
to turn it on, and it only has four settings--indoor, cloudy, fine and 
clear. (Although I can't tell you what the difference between "fine" and 
"clear" is.) There's no zoom.

The wee photos spring from the top, tickling your brow seconds after you 
click the shutter and developing within a minute or so. Photos are small 
enough to tuck in a wallet and still have a tab for Sharpie labeling. 
Loading film is easy, shots are easily counted by number in the lower 
right-hand corner and the lens is simple enough to get the job done.

Polaroid's vice president of marketing, David Miller, is the first to 
admit that for most people, the Polaroid 300 is a "secondary camera."

And for good reason: the film is a precious commodity. Each pack of film 
costs $9.99, so it's a $1 a photo. As someone with thousands of photos 
on my hard drive, the changing economics turned me into a more cautious, 
neurotic photographer. What if my photo turned out blurry? What if I 
loved a photo and wanted to email, TwitPic or Flickr it? What if I lost 
the business-card-sized Polaroid printout? My memory would be gone forever.

The designers of the Polaroid 300 were smart to avoid reinventing the 
Polaroid 300 as something it isn't: a high-resolution digital camera. 
The gadget is delightfully illogical: photos are expensive, it weighs 
down a tote bag and the photo resolution pales in comparison to even the 
first digital I bought in 2004. The Polaroid had fun and frustrating 
surprises like mysterious blotches, over exposure, and washed-out faces.

"People actually like the soft focus and graininess of colors," Mr. 
Miller told me, after I asked him about whether we'd ever see a higher 
resolution Polaroid. "That's part of the nostalgia."

When I took the camera with me to Baltimore to cover a kinetic sculpture 
race, the snapshots turned out darker than the bright digital shots and 
the weight in my bag was not welcome after 12 hours on my feet. I found 
that the Polaroid 300 worked best in daylight, like old-school cameras.

Action shots will be blurry – a photo of me doing a cartwheel blurred, 
making me look like a breakdancer. Not what I intended, but still looked 
kind of cool. Since the photos are always going to be tiny, I didn't 
bother trying to shoot landscapes, but found the camera was best for 
shooting portraits of friends. It's the high-heels of photography: 
poised for parties, but awkward if I was trying to do anything remotely 
active.

Over the past few years, I've become a camera phone photog, appreciating 
the shareability and "good enough" quality of iPhone pics. But I noticed 
that when I pointed the Polaroid at people, they seemed to smile wider 
than when they had a phone in their faces. Plus, they had a souvenir. 
One portrait subject reveled in the hip hues the Polaroid film cast on 
his face. Another yelped: "Am I really that pale?"

Is the Polaroid 300 worth it? The camera took me back to simpler times; 
when we didn't feel the need to see our pores in party shots or dispatch 
our vacation slideshows to millions of strangers online. When 
photographs were treasures to be shared with people close to us.

Even so this gadget is probably best left to the company's hard-core 
followers -- if there are some who aren't already loading up their 
vintage Polaroid cameras with film from the Impossible Project. For the 
rest of us, this camera feels a bit like a Walkman and a cache of 
cassette tapes -- a fun diversion, but no substitute for digital.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to