Feb. 15, 2011 10:00 AM Cable's Least Wanted: 10 channels that could be replaced by Al Jazeera and no one would care
By AARON BARNHART The Kansas City Star http://www.kansascity.com/2011/02/15/2656461/10-channels-that-could-be-replaced.html When Keith Olbermann announced he would be bringing his special blend of news and conflict to Current, a cable channel founded in 2005 by an investment group that included Al Gore, industry ratings expert Brad Adgate couldn’t help himself. He got on Twitter and posted Current’s Nielsen rating — just 23,000 viewers in prime time for the fourth quarter of 2010. To give you some idea how pathetic that number is, most mid-sized cities have a CW affiliate that draws a bigger audience. And of course, your typical CW affiliate is only carried in a fraction of the 60 million homes nationwide that have Current on their cable or satellite systems. To obtain this damning ratings information, Adgate — who’s research director for Horizon Media in New York — had to consult a document that Nielsen publishes every quarter but does not widely distribute. It’s called the Cable Network Audience Composition Report, and it’s the only public source for ratings information for several channels including Current. The fall 2010 CNAC report marked the first time Current has paid for Nielsen ratings in its five years of existence. Frankly, I’m surprised Current didn’t pay Nielsen not to publish these numbers. Current was watched in 18,000 households in prime time last fall (a figure Adgate extrapolated to 23,000 total viewers). No channel measured by Nielsen draws a smaller audience. During an interview with Olbermann, Gore and Current co-founder Joel Hyatt, I asked someone to confirm that Current’s ratings averaged in the low five figures. Gore spoke up. “The audience is higher than that,” he said, “and it’s going up every month.” So I asked if Current’s audience numbers were more like “the mid five figures.” “Higher,” said Gore, and now I was playing number-guess with a former Vice President, Nobel laureate and Oscar winner. “The upper five figures, low six figures?” I tried. There was a pause, then Hyatt said, “Yes.” The good news for Current is that it won’t be counting its audience in the high five figures, at least not when Olbermann is on the air. But there are other channels in the CNAC report with numbers almost as abysmal as Current’s. For instance, between 7 a.m. and 10 a.m. weekdays no fewer than 18 channels draw hash marks (<<), meaning that fewer than 0.1 percent of households that receive that channel are viewing it at those hours. The hash-mark channels include TV Guide Channel, Golf Channel and, sorry to say, BBC America. It’s possible they are airing paid programs at that hour, because infomercials are notoriously low-rated. But that only begs the question of why these networks are unable to make money any other way, such as rerunning their prime-time programs. So, with help from Adgate, I compiled a list of what I’m calling Cable’s Least Wanted, 10 channels that have been in existence at least three years — in most cases, much longer — and their prime-time nightly average for fourth quarter 2010: Current (18,000 households) DIY (80,000 households) ESPN Classic (19,000 households) Fox Soccer Channel (33,000 households) GAC (49,000 households) Logo (39,000 households) Outdoor (46,000 households) RFD-TV (56,000 households) Sleuth (81,000 households) VH1 Classic (31,000 households) To offer some baselines, top-rated ESPN averaged 2.683 million households, third-place news channel CNN 354,000 households, perennial BET challenger TV One 151,000 households and Fox Business, the home of Don Imus, averaged 39,000 households in fourth quarter 2010 (Fox Biz hasn’t been around long enough to make the least-wanted list). It’s worth noting that Discovery Health averaged 195,000 households in its last ratings period before it was merged with FitTV to make way for the Oprah Winfrey Network. Unlike Current, the rest of Cable’s Least Wanted don’t have a ratings savior waiting in the wings. Many of them have been propped up by their parent companies for years. They are widely distributed. They have marketing staffs and promotional budgets. They have had plenty of time to reach an audience. They have never, to my knowledge, contributed to our understanding of the Middle East. It’s worth asking why they continue to take up bandwidth in tens of millions of homes. It’s certainly worth asking if you’re one of the 7 million Americans who recently had to stream the unrest in Egypt on Al Jazeera English because it wasn’t on your cable system. The answer is that, other than Current, most low-rated cable channels are owned by media conglomerates that have included them as part of package deals with your cable or satellite provider. That’s why you hear cable companies continuing to insist that channel space is too precious to waste on adding a world news service. They couldn’t drop these losers if they wanted to. What was that thing Olbermann was saying the other day about cable TV content that was free from corporate interference? Read more: http://www.kansascity.com/2011/02/15/2656461/10-channels-that-could-be-replaced.html#ixzz1E44vr2rl -- ================================================= George Antunes Voice (713) 743-3923 Associate Professor Fax (713) 743-3927 Political Science Mail: antunes at uh dot edu University of Houston Houston, TX 77204-3011 _______________________________________________ Medianews mailing list [email protected] http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews
