http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/80a5279e-39f3-11e0-82aa-00144feabdc0.html#ixzz
1EEHI4tPC

Bubble trouble over sky-high internet values

By Richard Waters

Published: February 16 2011 19:02 | Last updated: February 16 2011 19:02

Talk of bubble trouble is rife again in Silicon Valley. Private internet
companies with names barely known in the financial world a year ago are
suddenly the focus of heated price-talk - even if they have yet to prove
they can raise money at some of these lofty levels.

Zynga, a social gaming company valued at about $5bn by private share
sales little more than three months ago, is looking to raise a fresh
round of capital at a valuation of $9bn or so, according to one person
familiar with its plans. Groupon, the group-buying site that turned down
a $6bn buy-out offer from Google late last year, is entertaining pitches
from bankers looking to take it public this year at a value of
$15bn-$20bn. And Facebook, the social networking site that only last
month was accorded a $50bn valuation in a deal led by Goldman Sachs, is
said to be considering helping its staff sell some of their stock, at a
valuation of $60bn.

Given how quickly figures like these have escalated in a matter of
weeks, it's tempting to write it all off as the product of an overheated
market, made worse by a lack of much real information about the
performance of these private companies.

Such a blanket dismissal would be to ignore the bigger forces at work.
Social networking and the mobile internet are changing the nature of
online behaviour, and technology sea-changes like this have a habit of
throwing up new leaders - though they are often also an excuse for a
good, old-fashioned investment bubble.

There are three basic tests for the new band of internet darlings:
whether they have found a profitable revenue model; whether the markets
they are creating will turn out to be big enough to support their
valuations; and what impact competition will eventually have on
constraining both their growth rates and profit margins.

On the first two counts, there is already evidence of some powerful
forces at work. Groupon, according to one person familiar with its
finances, anticipates that its revenues could double this year, reaching
$3.5bn-$4bn - roughly half of which the company pockets, with the rest
going to the merchants who are its customers.

By one estimate, meanwhile, Zynga is expecting revenues this year to
jump by 150-200 per cent from the near-$1bn it reached last year. The
group, which makes most of its money from selling virtual goods to
people who play games, such as FarmVille, while on Facebook, also has a
highly profitable business model.

Zynga's success has a knock-on effect on Facebook itself: thanks to the
30 per cent tax it collects on revenues Zynga generates from Facebook's
users, a large chunk of the games company's earnings fall straight to
Facebook's own bottom line.

By this test, Twitter, the micro-blogging site, still remains the most
glaring example of a consumer internet company whose value is based more
on hope than business achievement. In spite of an effort nearly 18
months ago to shift its focus to making money, Twitter's revenues are
still projected to reach little more than $100m this year. Talk of its
value has ranged widely (and wildly) in recent weeks, from $4bn to $8bn
or more.

But are the growth rates and profit margins of these new stars
sustainable in the face of rising competition? This is where things get
harder to call. With low barriers to entry, the internet can be a
ruthless place. E-commerce has turned out to be a highly price-sensitive
endeavour, where volume counts - and there are already powerful players
to contend with.

The bull case rests on the "category killer" argument: that network
effects, brand recognition and the chance to reach massive scale faster
than the competition combine to give the early players in any new online
market an unassailable lead.

This theory is about to be put to the test. Groupon's conspicuous
success with offering "daily deals" on the internet seems to have put it
in the crosshairs of every e-commerce and local advertising company
around. The test will be whether it can reach significant scale quickly
enough to withstand the inevitable decline in its margins.

Zynga, meanwhile, is in the hits business - a precarious place to make a
living, as many games companies have discovered to their cost. Through
massive data-mining of the online behaviour of its users, and by
cross-promoting new games to its already sizeable audience, Zynga is now
out to show that it can insulate itself against the vagaries of online
fashion.

Even if the early category killers can support their valuations, what of
the many other start-ups hoping to follow in their wake? Much of the
money being thrown at private internet companies is in search of new
markets, or at "me-too" companies that hope to emulate the success of
others.

The history of the dotcom bubble illustrates the risk that goes with
this kind of wishful thinking and copycat investing. There will be
winners - but a lot of blood will get spilt along the way.
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to