http://gcn.com/Articles/2011/02/18/Cybersecurity-bill-no-kill-switch.asp
x?p=1

Legislation, which revamps FISMA, would allow shutdowns of affected
systems in emergencies

    * By William Jackson
    * Feb 18, 2011

Sen. Joseph Lieberman (I-Conn.) is introducing a wide-ranging
cybersecurity bill that would revamp the Federal Information Security
Management Act and establish executive oversight of critical
infrastructure but would prohibit shutting down the Internet.

The Internet Freedom Act, which has not yet been filed and assigned a
number, is a reworking of the controversial Protecting Cyberspace as a
National Asset Act of 2010, S. 3480. It is sponsored by Lieberman, who
is chair of the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs
Committee; ranking member Susan Collins (R-Maine); and Federal Financial
Management Subcommittee Chairman Tom Carper (D-Del.).

"We want to clear the air once and for all," Lieberman said in a
statement announcing the bill. "There is no so-called 'kill switch' in
our legislation because the very notion is antithetical to our goal of
providing precise and targeted authorities to the president.
Furthermore, it is impossible to turn off the Internet in this country."

The bill does include provisions for the president to declare a national
cyber emergency and require implementation of response plans. It also
limits the duration of such declared emergencies without congressional
approval, limits the actions under response plans to the least
disruptive required, and allows for judicial review of which systems are
covered as critical infrastructure under the bill.

The bill's preamble states that, "in the event of a cyberattack, it is
essential that the law clearly and unambiguously delineate limits on
what the federal government can and cannot do to protect the information
infrastructure that is essential to the reliable operation of the
Internet and the critical infrastructure of the nation; and neither the
president, the director of the National Center for Cybersecurity and
Communications, nor any other officer or employee of the federal
government should have the authority to shut down the Internet."

The bill also would require development of mandatory "prioritized and
risk-based controls" for agency IT systems, development of a
supply-chain security strategy, and creation of a workforce development
and recruitment program.

The most controversial part of the bill is likely to be the provisions
for an emergency declaration and imposition of controls on privately
owned infrastructure.

Under the bill, the president can declare an emergency "if there is an
ongoing or imminent action by any individual or entity to exploit a
cyber risk in a manner that disrupts, attempts to disrupt, or poses a
significant risk of disruption to the operation of the information
infrastructure essential to the reliable operation of covered critical
infrastructure."

The declaration would specify the critical infrastructure involved and
the owners and operators, who will have to implement previously
established response plans. The director of the National Center for
Cybersecurity and Communications, established in DHS by the Homeland
Security Act of 2002, is to "ensure that emergency measures or actions
directed under this section represent the least disruptive means
feasible to the operations of the covered critical infrastructure and to
the national information infrastructure"

Traffic on the specified systems can be stopped only when nothing else
will work, and government would be prohibited from taking control of the
critical infrastructure or intercepting traffic.

The emergency declaration lasts 30 days but can be extended for up to
three additional 30-day periods. After that, a joint resolution from
Congress - both the Senate and House - is required to extend the
emergency for an additional 120 days.

The Homeland Security Department would establish a list of covered
critical infrastructure along with the criteria for selection. Systems
cannot be included based on activities protected by First Amendment,
that is, by the nature of the content they carry. Owners and operators
can appeal inclusion on the list in federal court.

The bill also requires development of a national strategy to improve the
security and resiliency of cyberspace, and establishes an Office of
Cyberspace Policy in the Executive Office of the President to develop
the national strategy as well as to "oversee, coordinate, and integrate
all policies and activities of the federal government across all
instruments of national power relating to ensuring the security and
resiliency of cyberspace." It also would be responsible for ensuring
"that all federal agencies comply with appropriate guidelines, policies
and directives from [DHS], other federal agencies with responsibilities
relating to cyberspace security or resiliency, and the National Center
for Cybersecurity and communications"

The director of office would review agency budget requests for
implementing the national strategy and make recommendations if they are
lacking.

Title III of the bill essentially rewrites FISMA and requires a
"comprehensive framework for ensuring the effectiveness of information
security controls over information resources that support the federal
information infrastructure and the operations and assets of agencies"
with "prioritized and risk-based controls."

The required controls would be developed and enforced by the National
Center for Cybersecurity and Communications. These would include
automated and continuous monitoring and would generally tighten up
requirements for security and accountability. Agencywide information
security programs would also be required.

A Federal Information Security Task Force of senior government employees
would be created for selecting best practices and coordinating
information sharing between agencies.

A supply-chain security policy "to enhance, in a risk-based and
cost-effective manner, the security of the communications and
information technology products and services purchased by the federal
government," would be developed by DHS; the Director of Cyberspace
Policy; Director of the National Center for Cybersecurity and
Communications; the secretaries of Defense, Commerce and State; the
Director of National Intelligence; General Services administrator; the
administrator of Federal Procurement Policy; and the CIO Council. The
policy would be incorporated into the Federal Acquisitions Regulations.

In addition, the Office of Personnel Management and Office of Management
and Budget would be required to assess workforce needs and develop
five-year plan for federal recruitment. A training curriculum for
cybersecurity workers would be developed and training requirements
established.
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to