February 20, 2011

U.S. Sets 21st-Century Goal: Building a Better Patent Office
By EDWARD WYATT
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/21/business/21patent.html?_r=1&ref=business&pagewanted=print


WASHINGTON — President Obama, who emphasizes American innovation, says 
modernizing the federal Patent and Trademark Office is crucial to 
“winning the future.” So at a time when a quarter of patent applications 
come from California, and many of those from Silicon Valley, the patent 
office is opening its first satellite office — in Detroit.

That is only one of the signs that have many critics saying that the 
office has its head firmly in the 20th century, if not the 19th.

Only in the last three years has the office begun to accept a majority 
of its applications in digital form. Mr. Obama astonished a group of 
technology executives last year when he described how the office has to 
print some applications filed by computer and scan them into another, 
incompatible computer system.

“There is no company I know of that would have permitted its information 
technology to get into the state we’re in,” David J. Kappos, who 18 
months ago became director of the Patent and Trademark Office and 
undersecretary of commerce for intellectual property, said in a recent 
interview. “If it had, the C.E.O. would have been fired, the board would 
have been thrown out, and you would have had shareholder lawsuits.”

Once patent applications are in the system, they sit — for years. The 
patent office’s pipeline is so clogged it takes two years for an 
inventor to get an initial ruling, and an additional year or more before 
a patent is finally issued.

The delays and inefficiencies are more than a nuisance for inventors. 
Patentable ideas are the basis for many start-up companies and small 
businesses. Venture capitalists often require start-ups to have a patent 
before offering financing. That means that patent delays cost jobs, slow 
the economy and threaten the ability of American companies to compete 
with foreign businesses.

Much of the patent office’s decline has occurred in the last 13 years, 
as the Internet age created a surge in applications. In 1997, 2.25 
patents were pending for every one issued. By 2008, that rate had nearly 
tripled, to 6.6 patents pending for every one issued. The figure fell 
below six last year.

Though the office’s ranks of patent examiners and its budget have 
increased by about 25 percent in the last five years, that has not been 
enough to keep up with a flood of applications — which grew to more than 
2,000 a day last year, for a total of 509,000, from 950 a day in 1997.

The office, like a few other corners of the government, has long paid 
its way, thanks to application and maintenance fees. That income — $2.1 
billion last year — has made it an inviting target for Congress, which 
over the last 20 years has diverted a total of $800 million to other 
uses, rather than letting the office invest the money in its operations.

Applications have also become far more complex, said Douglas K. Norman, 
president of the Intellectual Property Owners Association, a trade group 
mainly of large technology and manufacturing companies.

“When I was a young patent lawyer, a patent application would be 20 to 
25 pages and have 10 to 15 claims,” Mr. Norman said. A claim is the part 
of the patent that defines what is protected. “Now they run hundreds of 
pages, with hundreds, and sometimes thousands, of claims.”

Lost in the scrutiny of the office’s logjam, however, was the fact that 
the number of patents issued reached a record last year — more than 
209,000, or 29 percent more than the average of 162,000 a year over the 
previous four years. Rejections also hit a high of 258,000 — not a 
measure of quality, Mr. Kappos said, but a sign of greater efficiency.

Between the backlog of 700,000 patents awaiting their first action by an 
examiner and the 500,000 patents that are in process, a total of 1.2 
million applications are pending.

Sitting in his suburban Virginia office, not far from a model of the 
light bulb Edison presented for patent in November 1879 (which was 
approved two and a half months later), Mr. Kappos proudly ticked off 
figures that he said proved the agency was heading in the right direction.

The backlog has actually declined about 10 percent from a peak of 
770,000 at the end of 2008.

“We were able to work a 13-month year last year,” he said, referring to 
the productivity increase in 2010 over the 2009. “We are processing a 
far larger workload with the same number of examiners.”

Still, Mr. Kappos wants to add more than 1,000 examiners in each of the 
next two years, a 30 percent increase. Mr. Obama’s 2012 budget calls for 
a 28 percent increase in spending, to $2.7 billion, over 2010. In two 
consecutive sessions, Congress has defeated a bill that would allow the 
patent office to keep all of the fees it collects. While another similar 
effort is under way, a big staffing increase will not be easy in a 
climate of cuts.

Mr. Kappos, a former electrical engineer and lawyer who joined the 
patent office in 2009 after 27 years at I.B.M., has improved relations 
with the union representing patent examiners. He and the union agreed on 
performance evaluation measures last year, the first time in 50 years 
that the yardsticks had been revised.

“I give David Kappos a good deal of credit for seeing where the problems 
have been and being willing to address them,” said Robert D. Budens, 
president of the union, the Patent Office Professional Association. “I 
think it’s a little early to see the full extent of the changes. But we 
have seen an increase in morale and a decrease in attrition, which is 
now almost the lowest it’s been since I came here” in 1990.

Patent applications come from all over the United States, and the office 
has forgone satellite offices — until now. Last year, the office 
announced it would put about 100 examiners in Detroit. Some prominent 
lawmakers from Michigan have worked on patent issues, including 
Representative John Conyers Jr., a Detroit Democrat who, when the 
decision was made, was chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, which 
oversees patents.

Mr. Kappos said he chose Detroit because it had a large communities of 
patent lawyers and agents, nearby universities and transportation 
centers, and relatively low costs of living and real estate. “Detroit 
has long been an innovation center,” he said. “It’s undervalued, and 
that is where we want to invest.” He said it would also attract a work 
force with more varied skills.

Mr. Kappos is also pushing an initiative that would charge patent 
applicants a higher fee to guarantee that their applications will 
receive a ruling within a year. But that initiative and others are not 
enough, said Paul R. Michel, who recently retired as chief judge for the 
United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in Washington, 
the main forum for patent appeals.

“The office can’t be made efficient in 18 months without a vast increase 
in finances,” said Mr. Michel, who has made evangelizing for an overhaul 
of the office a pet cause. “Small efficiency improvements will only make 
a small difference in the problem.”

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to