Son of ACTA: meet the next secret copyright treaty

By Nate Anderson
Ars Technica

March 11, 2011

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2011/03/son-of-acta-meet-the-next-secret-copyright-treaty.ars


So many countries in need of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, so 
little time! The US government, still trying to secure final passage for 
the drafted-in-secret Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement (ACTA), has 
already turned its attention to a new multilateral trade agreement that 
will bring the wonders of the DMCA to countries like Australia, Brunei, 
Chile, Singapore, Malaysia, and Vietnam.

The new Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP), like the ACTA before it, had 
its intellectual property chapter drafted by the US. Once again, the 
chapter was drafted in secret and has been classified for at least four 
years after negotiations end. The agreement exports (nearly verbatim) 
the DMCA's rules on digital locks, ISP liability, and subscriber 
disconnections, with a few extra goodies on the side.

TPP has been in the drafting stage for some time, but the US 
intellectual property chapter (PDF) only leaked yesterday. Canadian law 
professor Michael Geist calls it "everything [the US] wanted in ACTA but 
didn't get."

"For example," he says, "the digital lock rules are the US DMCA, 
complete with [the] exact same exceptions (no more, no less). The term 
of copyright matches the US term of life of the author plus 70 years, 
beyond the Berne requirement and Canadian law. The ISP provisions 
including a copy of the US notice-and-takedown system as well as 
provisions that go beyond US law. In other words, the US envisions using 
the TPP to export its copyright law to as many countries as possible 
while creating backdoor changes to its own domestic laws."

The draft contains only a "placeholder" section for limitations and 
exceptions such as fair use, but it contains plenty of detail on 
enforcement. Every TPP country must create "legal incentives for 
[Internet] service providers to cooperate with copyright owners in 
deterring the unauthorized storage and transmission of copyrighted 
materials." ISPs must cut off access to "repeat infringers" of 
copyright. And bypassing DRM is only permissible for good-faith security 
and privacy research, or if you run a library.

The chapter requires criminal penalties against anyone who uses "an 
audiovisual recording device to transmit or make a copy of a motion 
picture… In a public motion picture exhibition facility.” All countries 
must provide a "making available" right to copyright holders, such that 
simply offering a file through BitTorrent would be grounds for a lawsuit 
even if no one downloaded the file. Boxes meant "primarily" for 
descrambling cable and satellite transmissions would be illegal and 
subject to criminal penalties.

Any country could adopt tougher copyright and patent penalties than 
those in the TPP, but no signatory could do anything less. This follows 
a consistent international pattern in which protection and enforcement 
standards are always mandatory, while exceptions and limitations are 
usually optional.

Knowledge Ecology International (KEI), which obtained the leaked 
document, also notes that "copyright damages shall consider the 
suggested retail price or other legitimate measure of value submitted by 
the right holder" in court cases. And all countries must set up a 
process to identify "Internet users for any ISP, going beyond US case law."


Calling for Congress

While KEI has numerous concerns about the content of the leaked chapter, 
it has a larger concern about the process by which such chapters are 
drafted and negotiated. As with the ACTA, by the time the negotiators 
release a text for public comment, few major changes are still possible.

"The document has been distributed to all member states participating in 
the TPP negotiations, so it is not secret from any of the parties in the 
negotiations. The document may also be subject to review by the hundreds 
of corporate insiders who serve on USTR [US Trade Representative] 
advisory board. It is, however, secret from the taxpayers and voters who 
live in the United States, and people everywhere who are going to live 
under the new norms…

"KEI objects to the policy of making the negotiating text of 
intellectual property agreements secret, particularly when the documents 
are distributed to all parties in a negotiations, and thus are only 
secret from the public. The Congress needs to intervene and require that 
such texts be made public routinely."

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to