Major report debunks alleged link between piracy and terrorism

By Nate Anderson
Ars Technica

February 16, 2011

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2011/03/even-commercial-pirates-now-have-to-compete-with-free.ars


On February 15, the film industry, the movie business, video game 
publishers, and business software developers submitted a massive report 
to the US government, as they do every year. That report, part of 
America's "Special 301" process, is a key tool used each year to develop 
a list of other countries that the US wants to pressure on intellectual 
property laws. This year's version alleged that piracy is now, in many 
countries, a product of organized crime (PDF). And it claimed that 
pirated DVDs are worth more than cocaine.

Such claims have been made many times over the last decade, but a major 
new report, funded by Canada and by the Ford Foundation and buttressed 
by fieldwork around the globe, suggests that neither assertion is true. 
Indeed, far from being supremely lucrative, commercial piracy is under 
pressure from the same force pressing on legal distribution: free 
Internet file-sharing.

As for the drugs... well, there's a reason the gangs in The Wire weren't 
selling bootlegs of Spider-Man 3. There's just not much money in it anymore.


Linkages

The recent Section 301 industry submission isn't shy about making broad 
claims about piracy and organized crime. Consider the following 
statement, drawn from a single footnote in the report:

Piracy has been taken over in many countries by organized crime 
syndicates; this includes both physical and online piracy phenomena… A 
March 2009 study explored the linkages between organized crime and film 
piracy detailing 14 case studies of film piracy, providing compelling 
evidence of a broad, geographically dispersed connection between piracy 
and organized crime. As well as documenting cases in North America and 
Europe, the report outlines the involvement of organized crime with film 
piracy in South America, Russia and many parts of Asia…

That study once again showed that the mark-up for DVD piracy (a 
relatively low-risk activity) is much higher than that for cocaine and 
heroine trafficking. The private sector does not possess the tools, nor 
usually the authority within countries, to investigate and fight 
organized crime. In addition, such organized groups or other commercial 
pirates can become violent, and company representatives and counsel have 
in some countries experienced threats on their lives, physical 
intimidation, or attacks leading to injury when doing their jobs to 
investigate piracy, and this has prevented enforcement activity by the 
private sector in many instances. Therefore, governments must step up to 
this challenge.

Such rhetoric has become standard. The "2009 study" referenced above 
comes from the RAND Corporation, and it's called "Film Piracy, Organized 
Crime, and Terrorism" (PDF). Funded by the motion picture business, most 
of the report's primary data came from someone "serving as an 
organized-crime consultant to the [Motion Picture Association]."

That report opens by claiming that DVD piracy "has a higher profit 
margin than narcotics and minimal risks of enforcement," making it 
"attractive around the world as an element of criminal portfolios that 
also include drugs, money laundering, extortion, and human smuggling."

And it's not just drug gangs; piracy is "attractive not only to 
organized crime, but also to terrorists, particularly opportunistic 
members of local terrorist cells."

A few years earlier, the worldwide music lobby put out its own report 
(PDF) called "Music Piracy: Serious, Violent, and Organized Crime."

"Evidence is available, and case studies in this leaflet demonstrate, 
the connections between music piracy and other crimes, such as people 
trafficking, money laundering, violence, drug smuggling and terrorism," 
it says.

But is that true? After three years of work by 35 researchers, the new 
study finds "no evidence" of systematic links between piracy and serious 
organized crime or terrorism. As for the claim about DVDs being a better 
business than narcotics, the report has one word for this claim: 
"implausible."


Better than drugs

Take the DVDs-better-than-drugs claim. The authors of the Social Science 
Research Council report, "Media Piracy in Emerging Economies," call it 
"an implausible claim that has circulated in industry literature since 
at least 2004."

They trace the story back to a 2001 French magazine article which 
claimed that a kilo of pirate CDs was worth more than a kilo of 
marijuana. Interpol ran with the claim in 2003, and "from there it began 
a long life of circular citation in industry reports."

The authors update the claim by comparing a kilo of marijuana in New 
York (street value: $30,000) to a kilo of pirate DVDs (65 discs, 
averaging $5 each, or $325). While some piracy was lucrative in the 
early 2000s, "we see no evidence that piracy, outside a few niche 
markets, is still a high-margin business," they conclude.

As for broader links between organized crime, terrorism, and piracy, the 
authors are also skeptical—though the connection depends in large part 
on what one means by "organized crime."

Commercial-scale piracy is illegal, and its clandestine production and 
supply chains invariably require organization. It meets, in this 
respect, a minimal definition of organized crime. Pirated CD and DVD 
vending, moreover, is often concentrated in poor neighborhoods and 
informal markets where other types of illegal activity are common. Such 
contexts create points of intersection between the pirate economy and 
wider illegal and quasi-legal arrangements of the informal economy. It 
would be remarkable if they did not. But we found no evidence of 
systematic links between media piracy and more serious forms of 
organized crime, much less terrorism, in any of our country studies.

The country studies used researchers who, in many cases, had 
long-established familiarity with their regions. In Mexico, for 
instance, one author notes that he has been in touch with key street 
vending groups there "for twenty years," and he criticizes the RAND 
report for apparently relying "exclusively on newspaper stories and 
interviews with representatives of the copyright industry" while doing 
its work.

RAND noted that in places like China or Russia, "on-site investigations 
are difficult or dangerous, or both, so we were compelled to rely more 
heavily on published accounts." The SSRC chapter on Russia, in contrast, 
relied on:

* Fieldwork in St. Petersburg conducted by Sezneva, Pachenkov, and 
Olympieva in 2008 and 2009
* Twenty interviews of industry lawyers, judges, and legal scholars and 
representatives of non-governmental and non-commercial organizations 
involved in enforcement
* A March 2009 focus group with heavy users of unlicensed content in St. 
Petersburg
* A late-2008 survey of three hundred DVD consumers in the city of Irkutsk
* Content analysis of Russian-language media and online forums
* Contributions from our economic and industry research partners, 
especially Anatoly Kozyrev
* A wide array of secondary sources

The SSRC report, at more than 450+ pages, is nothing if not thorough.


Competing with free

One of its intriguing findings is that even the commercial pirates have 
it tough these days. Piracy made money back when optical disc stampers 
were scarce and expensive; it became less lucrative when CD and DVD 
burners became commodity items. Today, under pressure from P2P 
distribution, optical disc piracy in wealthy countries is "all but 
eliminated" and profit margins elsewhere are slim.

"Increasingly, commercial pirates face the same dilemma as the legal 
industry," says the report, "how to compete with free."

In a widely cited piece from 2008, our own Julian Sanchez dug into the 
claim that IP infringement killed 750,000 jobs and cost US industries 
$200 billion to $250 billion. The numbers turned out to be "utterly 
bogus," as Sanchez noted, but they had been repeated as articles of 
faith for two decades. Since that article appeared, this particular 
claim doesn't feature in much pro-IP testimony. Is it time to drop some 
of the most inflammatory rhetoric about "terrorism" and drug 
trafficking, too?

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to