ISPs don't want to be Big Content's "judges, juries, and executioners"

By Matthew Lasar
Ars Technica

March 16, 2011

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2011/03/aussie-dsl-service-time-to-get-isps-out-of-copyright-enforcement.ars


Australia's second largest DSL service has clearly had it with the 
burden of copyright enforcement being placed on Internet Service 
Providers. iiNet recently won a case in which a court confirmed that 
ISPs are not copyright cops; a judge ruled that they don't have an 
automatic duty to sanction subscribers upon receipt of piracy 
allegations against them.

But iiNet doesn't just want to prevail in Australia's legal system. It 
wants to promote an alternative to the ISP-as-enforcer model, outlined 
in a new paper titled "Encouraging Legitimate Use of Online Content."

The "Hollywood solution," as the ISP calls it in a new position paper, 
is "unattractive and unsatisfactory, to say the least." Content owners 
deploy private detectives "to trawl the public Internet," then hand over 
the data to the cable and telco broadband providers, who become de facto 
judges, juries and executioners.

Nowhere in this "pseudo 'trial and conviction', process is there an 
independent body who is required to verify the quality of the content 
owners' assertions," iiNet protests, "determine the severity of the 
infringement" or "determine the level of warning notice and/or 
punishment to be imposed."

So iiNet proposes just that: an "independent body" model, which would 
look like this:
Four steps to discovery

First, content owners will do their own detective work in searching out 
the relevant IP addresses of alleged file sharing miscreants.

Second, the "independent body" will determine whether the evidence 
submitted meets an appropriate legal standard.

Third, if it does, the independent body will contact the relevant ISP 
and ask for details about the service account holder.

Fourth, with those contact details, the body will issue "notices" 
warning an account holder that she has been detected sharing 
unauthorized copies, offer "educative information," and "advise the 
consequences" that could follow if the same behavior continues.

The independent body will keep records, monitor the behavior of repeat 
infringers, and seek additional sanctions. "Some of those sanctions may 
include fines, court charges, or changes to the internet service." 
Consumers will be able to challenge allegations to the independent body, 
or raise an insecure wireless issue with their ISP.
Penalties

iiNet is uncomfortable not only with being central to the infringer 
identification process, but with being the arbiter of the punishment 
process as well.

"In an age where Internet access is being determined by countries such 
as France that 'free access to public communication services online' is 
a right laid down in the Declaration of Human Rights 7, or the 
equivalent of access to education, the notion of disconnection without 
judicial oversight violates the presumption of innocence," iiNet warns. 
"As the penalty for possibly minor economic loss (at the individual 
infringer level) removal of Internet access is, therefore, both 
inappropriate and disproportionate."

So the company proposes a "traffic offense" model for punishing illegal 
file sharers. A scale of fines could be set up, "relative to the 
economic loss represented." Other sanctions could also be established. 
"These could involve charges being laid for treatment by the courts or 
possibly shaping of peer to peer traffic."

But the ISP "does not believe that termination of access for an entire 
household, or a business, as a result of one individual’s infringement, 
is ever appropriate or proportional," the essay emphasizes.

Obviously iiNet knows that publishing something like this won't 
magically change the attitude of the content makers. We'd like to see 
some more details too, such as who will comprise these independent 
bodies to ensure their actual independence.

But given that Hollywood's approach to the problem is "totally 
unacceptable to ISPs, it is essential that another option is sought," 
the broadband provider insists. "Having considered the matter for some 
time, we believe that with good will and the support of all 
stakeholders, the model described here is worth serious consideration 
and support."

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to