March 21, 2011

Sharp Scrutiny for Merger of AT&T and T-Mobile
By EDWARD WYATT
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/22/technology/22regulate.html?ref=technology&pagewanted=print


WASHINGTON — Mega-mergers may be celebrated on Wall Street on the theory 
that bigger is better. But the proposed merger of AT&T and T-Mobile is 
likely to face intense scrutiny by regulators, lawmakers and consumer 
advocates.

The review of the merger, one of the largest deals since the 2008 
financial crisis, will also be a test for the White House. During his 
campaign, President Obama criticized the Bush administration’s record on 
antitrust review, and promised to increase scrutiny of merger proposals.

Some analysts say it is too early to see if the merger will pass muster. 
Part of the difficulty stems from the fact that the two primary agencies 
that will oversee any merger — the Federal Communications Commission and 
the Justice Department’s antitrust division — look at it with different 
goals in mind.

The Justice Department will chiefly examine whether competition among 
wireless mobile phone providers would remain sufficient after a merger. 
The department gave some hint to its thinking when it told the F.C.C. 
last year that the agency needed to use its “policy levers” to encourage 
more competition among wireless companies, particularly in wireless 
broadband access.

The F.C.C., on the other hand, has a goal of protecting the public 
interest in allocating use of the public airwaves, which it does in part 
by promoting competition. For example, one objective involves pushing 
the big wireless companies to allow smaller competitors to use their 
networks for data roaming services. Such policy initiatives give the 
F.C.C. more flexibility to consider conditions that it could apply to a 
merger to make it more palatable.

“Normally, competition and the public interest go hand in hand,” said 
Bert Foer, president of the American Antitrust Institute, a nonprofit 
agency that generally argues for more competition. But federal courts 
have recently sided with regulatory agencies instead of antitrust 
enforcers when conflicts occur, something that perhaps will give the 
F.C.C. the advantage in setting the conditions under which to approve a 
merger.

Congress, too, is likely to play a part in scrutinizing the proposed 
merger. Several Congressional committees have already announced plans to 
review the deal.

Senator John D. Rockefeller IV, a West Virginia Democrat who is chairman 
of the Senate Commerce Committee, said it was “absolutely essential” for 
both the Justice Department and the F.C.C. to “leave no stone unturned 
in determining what the impact of this combination is on the American 
people.”

Most recently, lawmakers and the White House faced stiff opposition from 
advocacy groups over the recent merger of Comcast and NBC Universal. 
That deal was approved by the Justice Department and the F.C.C. with 
several conditions that subject the expanded company to additional 
oversight, but many consumer groups and liberal advocacy organizations 
were unsatisfied with those terms.

“I’m not a huge fan of weighing down a merger with a dozen or more 
conditions,” said Gigi B. Sohn, president of Public Knowledge, a 
consumer advocacy group that sharply criticized the proposed merger of 
AT&T and T-Mobile. “As a regulator, you have to ask yourself how a 
merger could be in the public interest if you have to do all those 
things to it to get it done.”

AT&T is already pre-empting any concerns from lawmakers. Its publicity 
materials announcing the merger (including a dedicated Web site, 
mobilizeeverything.com), pulled language directly from the president’s 
State of the Union Message with references to providing wireless 
high-speed Internet to nearly all Americans in the next five years. And 
to help Senator Rockefeller with his deliberations, AT&T prominently 
displayed in its online materials a map of how the merger would expand 
service in West Virginia.

AT&T contends that the wireless phone market is highly competitive, with 
18 of the 20 largest United States markets each having five or more 
wireless competitors. That may help AT&T, as the Justice Department has 
traditionally looked at local competition when considering whether a 
proposed merger will substantially reduce consumer options, said Michael 
L. Weiner, a partner and co-chairman of the antitrust practice at 
Dechert, an international law firm.

But national competition also plays an important role in the wireless 
market. Many mobile phone customers base their buying decisions on 
whether they will have to pay expensive roaming charges when they travel 
out of their home area. And after the merger, AT&T and Verizon will 
between them control nearly 80 percent of the wireless market, with the 
third-largest competitor, Sprint, lagging far behind.

When AT&T Wireless merged with Cingular in 2004, it emphasized the 
national benefits of the joined companies, Mr. Weiner said. Now, it is 
making the opposite argument.

“We’re very confident that we can achieve a successful regulatory 
review,” Wayne Watts, a senior executive vice president and general 
counsel at AT&T, said Monday. “The facts show significant, unique public 
interest benefits from this transaction.”

AT&T also said that it expected to discuss some divestitures with 
regulators to get approval for the deal. Most likely, those would take 
the form of the company giving up some wireless airwaves in certain 
cities where the merger would leave too few competitors.

The F.C.C. could use its leverage over the parties in discussing those 
possible conditions, under the theory that a company trying to get 
approval for a merger is unlikely to strongly oppose its chief 
regulator’s policy goals.

For example, the agency has been trying to get the large wireless 
companies to allow customers of other providers to use their networks 
for data roaming, much as they allow for roaming for voice services. The 
big providers have been reluctant to do so, because data services use 
much more bandwidth and, as AT&T customers with iPhones know, that can 
greatly slow a network.

The F.C.C. also has voiced its desire to expand its policy of net 
neutrality, which requires that Internet service providers not slow or 
block specific content, to apply to wireless broadband services as well 
as to wired services.

Though the F.C.C.’s position on net neutrality for wired Internet 
service was opposed by many telecommunications companies, AT&T supported 
it. This month, amid its talks with T-Mobile, AT&T’s chief lobbyist, 
James W. Cicconi, testified to the company’s support of the F.C.C. 
policy before a hostile House subcommittee.

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to