March 24, 2011

A Radical Kind of Reactor
By KEITH BRADSHER
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/25/business/energy-environment/25chinanuke.html?_r=1&ref=business&pagewanted=print


SHIDAO, China — While engineers at Japan’s stricken nuclear power plant 
struggle to keep its uranium fuel rods from melting down, engineers in 
China are building a radically different type of reactor that some 
experts say offers a safer nuclear alternative.

The technology will be used in two reactors here on a peninsula jutting 
into the Yellow Sea, where the Chinese government is expected to let 
construction proceed even as the world debates the wisdom of nuclear power.

Rather than using conventional fuel rod assemblies of the sort leaking 
radiation in Japan, each packed with nearly 400 pounds of uranium, the 
Chinese reactors will use hundreds of thousands of billiard-ball-size 
fuel elements, each cloaked in its own protective layer of graphite.

The coating moderates the pace of nuclear reactions and is meant to 
ensure that if the plant had to be shut down in an emergency, the 
reaction would slowly stop on its own and not lead to a meltdown.

The reactors will also be cooled by nonexplosive helium gas instead of 
depending on a steady source of water — a critical problem with the 
damaged reactors at Japan’s Fukushima Daiichi power plant. And unlike 
those reactors, the Chinese reactors are designed to gradually dissipate 
heat on their own, even if coolant is lost.

If the new plants here prove viable, China plans to build dozens more of 
them in coming years.

The technology under construction here, known as a pebble-bed reactor, 
is not new. Germany, South Africa and the United States have all 
experimented with it, before abandoning it over technical problems or a 
lack of financing.

But as in many other areas of alternative energy, including solar panels 
and wind turbines, China is now taking the lead in actually building the 
next-generation technology. The government has paid for all of the 
research and development costs for the two pebble-bed reactors being 
built here, and will cover 30 percent of the construction costs.

Despite Japan’s crisis, China still plans to build as many as 50 nuclear 
reactors over the next five years — more than the rest of the world 
combined. Most of this next wave will be of more conventional designs.

But if the pebble-bed approach works as advertised, and proves cost 
effective, China hopes it can eventually adopt the technology on a broad 
scale to make nuclear power safer and more feasible as it deals with the 
world’s fastest growing economy and the material expectations of its 1.3 
billion people.

Western environmentalists are divided on the safety of pebble-bed 
nuclear technology.

Thomas B. Cochran, the senior scientist on nuclear power for the Natural 
Resources Defense Council, an American group, said that such reactors 
would probably be less dangerous than current nuclear plants, and might 
be better for the environment than coal-fired plants.

“Over all, in terms of design,” he said, “it would appear to be safer, 
with the following caveat: the safety of any nuclear plant is not just a 
function of the design but also of the safety culture of the plant.”

The executives overseeing construction of the new Chinese reactors say 
that engineers are already being trained to oversee the extensively 
computerized controls for the plant, using a simulator at a test reactor 
that has been operating for a decade near Beijing, apparently without 
mishap.

But Greenpeace, the international environmentalist group, opposes 
pebble-bed nuclear reactors, questioning whether any nuclear technology 
can be truly safe. Wrapping the uranium fuel in graphite greatly 
increases the volume of radioactive waste eventually requiring disposal, 
said Heinz Smital, a Greenpeace nuclear technology specialist in Germany.

But he said the waste is far less radioactive per ton than spent uranium 
fuel rods — one of the big sources of trouble at the Fukushima Daiichi 
plant.

China is building a repository for high-level nuclear waste, like 
conventional fuel rods, in the country’s arid west. But the far less 
radioactive spheres, or pebbles, like those from the Shidao reactors 
will not require such specialized storage; China plans to store the used 
pebbles initially at the power plants, and later at lower-level 
radioactive waste disposal sites near the reactors.

Whatever fears the rest of the world may have about China’s nuclear 
ambitions, the environmental cost-benefit analysis contains at least one 
potential positive: More nukes would let China reduce the heavy reliance 
on coal and other fossil fuels that now make it the world’s biggest 
emitter of global-warming gases.

“China epitomizes the stark choices that we face globally in moving away 
from current forms of coal-based electricity,” said Jonathan Sinton, the 
top China specialist at the International Energy Agency in Paris. 
“Nuclear is an essential alternative” to coal, he said. “It’s the only 
one that can provide the same quality of electricity at a similar scale 
in the medium and long term.”

Chinese leaders have been largely unwilling to engage in the global 
debate on climate change. But they have made a priority of reducing 
urban air pollution — which kills thousands of people every year and is 
largely caused by burning coal — and of improving mine safety. Coal 
mining accidents killed more than 2,400 people in China last year alone.

China’s biggest electric company, the state-owned Huaneng Group, now 
aims to prove that the technology can work on a commercial scale by 
building the two pebble-bed reactors — each capable of meeting the 
residential power needs of an American city of 75,000 to 100,000 people. 
The reactors are expected to go into operation in about four years.

The plants’ foundations have already been laid, their steel reinforcing 
bars pointing skyward, on a desolate landscape dominated by 
thatch-roofed huts and last season’s cornfields. Chinese safety 
regulations require that all nuclear plants be located at least 30 miles 
from the nearest city, in this case Rongcheng, which has a population of 
one million.

It was only three days after a tsunami swamped Japan’s Fukushima Daiichi 
plant that China’s legislature approved its five-year plan calling for 
dozens of new nuclear reactors. As the severity of that crisis became 
evident, Beijing said it would “temporarily suspend“ the approval of new 
nuclear reactors, but would allow construction to proceed at more than 
two dozen other nuclear projects already under way.

By coincidence, China’s cabinet and its national energy bureau had both 
given final approval for the pebble-bed reactors here in Shidao in the 
two weeks before the earthquake, said Xu Yuanhui, the father of China’s 
pebble-bed nuclear program.

China’s nuclear safety agency has met since the Japanese earthquake and 
reviewed the Shidao’s project plans and site preparation, and has 
indicated it will be the next project to receive safety clearance.

“The conclusion is clear that it is all ready to start to pour 
concrete,” said Dr. Xu, a former Tsinghua University professor who is 
now the vice general manager of Chinergy, the contractor building the 
reactors here.

Germany led the initial research into pebble-bed nuclear reactors and 
built its own research version in the 1960s. That reactor closed after 
an accident, caused by a jammed fuel pebble that released traces of 
radiation — coincidentally nine days after the Chernobyl accident in 
1986, at a time of greatly increased worry about nuclear safety. Dr. Xu 
said that China, learning from the German mishap, had designed its 
reactors to keep the pebbles from jamming.

South Africa tried hard until last summer to build a pebble-bed reactor 
but ran into serious cost overruns.

In the United States, the federal government and companies have spent 
heavily on pebble-bed research. But there has been little appetite for 
actually building new nuclear reactors — of any sort — since the Three 
Mile Island accident in 1979.

“The Chinese had a determination to build, to show the technology to 
work, and a commitment to get it done,” said Andrew Kadak, a 
Massachusetts Institute of Technology nuclear engineer specializing in 
pebble-bed reactors. “In the U.S. we didn’t have, and still don’t have, 
the commitment.”

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to