FCC says price counts in announcing new broadband plan
Phone subsidy program to expand to wireless broadband
By Center for Public Integrity - June 5th, 2015
The Federal Communications Commission, concerned about the high cost of
broadband, wants to put cell phones that can access the Internet in the
hands of America’s poor in hopes of reducing the digital divide.
FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler is proposing to beef up the $1.7 billion
Lifeline program, funded by charges on phone bills, and originally
created to subsidize the cost of landline phones. The program now
reaches 12 million families and has been expanded to limited-use cellphones.
The proposal is far from being a done deal — still to come are comments
on what a minimum service package should look like. For example, the
amount of data usage and voice minutes to be permitted will need to be
determined. Wheeler also asked for comments on how to increase
competition among mobile phone providers to reduce prices.
Wheeler hopes to reduce fraud and abuse in the oft-criticized subsidy
program, and shrink the digital divide. Whether that can be accomplished
through a wireless connection is an open question. The program does
nothing about wireline connections, which are faster, more robust and
cheaper than wireless phones.
Regardless, a disproportionate number of low-income families do not have
Internet connections of any sort, and low-cost wireless access may be
their best option. No connection means no easy access to the wealth of
online information that most Americans enjoy, such as health research,
job openings, education and training, and banking and government services.
Only 48 percent of households earning $25,000 or less have broadband at
home compared with 95 percent of households with incomes of $150,000 or
more, putting the poor at an even deeper economic disadvantage,
according to the FCC. Those percentages haven’t changed much in recent
years.
A long-running debate among Washington, D.C., policy analysts has been
how to reduce the divide. Some analysts and surveys say households
choose not to purchase broadband service because they either don’t have
the computer skills to navigate the Internet or they don’t think online
content is relevant to their lives.
Other analysts argue that the high price of broadband and a computer is
the biggest reason low-income families don’t buy Internet service. It’s
all in how you ask the question, as the Center for Public Integrity has
reported more than once.
Wheeler, in his proposal to reform the Lifeline program, is coming down
on the price side of the argument. And he has data that supports his
position.
In an FCC study that tested different subsidies, services and marketing
strategies for smartphones — and released just days before Wheeler’s
announcement — the agency concluded that price, not digital literacy,
was the determinant for previously unconnected users to buy a broadband
plan with a subsidized smartphone.
“Patterns within the data indicate that cost to consumers does have an
effect on adoption and which plans they choose,” the study’s authors
wrote. Requiring wireless carriers “to offer or provide digital literacy
training does not appear to be an efficient or effective model for
converting non-adopters to adopters.”
John Horrigan, who studied Internet adoption when working on the Obama
administration’s 2010 National Broadband Plan, said the FCC’s findings
support his research that shows price is the primary obstacle to
broadband adoption.
He added in an email, however, that while the FCC found that offering
training through carriers was not effective, “offering training through
community institutions (neighborhood nonprofits, libraries) is effective
and should be part of any overall broadband adoption strategy.”
While the distinction may seem inconsequential, it has big implications
on what policy the FCC should follow to reduce the digital divide. The
FCC is scheduled to vote on Wheeler’s proposal June 18.
This story was co-published with TIME.
--
*================================================
Duane Whittingham - N9SSN
(ARES/RACES, EmComm, Skywarn & Red Cross)
(Melrose Park Public Safety & Homeland Security)
http://www.mpdes.org
http://www.radiodude.info
================================================*
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net