Questions on Spectrum Animate T-Mobile-Dish Merger Talks
By REBECCA R. RUIZ
NY Times
JUNE 4, 2015
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/05/technology/spectrum-questions-animate-t-mobile-dish-merger-talks.html
At the center of the merger talks between T-Mobile and Dish Networks is
the value of spectrum, the airwaves that carry communications signals.
Spectrum brings to life everything from baby monitors and motorized
garage doors to cellphone connections and television shows. But it is a
limited resource, which puts it in high demand, particularly among
wireless carriers who must respond to ever-rising data use on mobile
phones in the United States.
Different types of spectrum — ranging in frequency from low to high —
are suited to different uses; the type that carries mobile phone
communications most reliably, known as low-frequency spectrum, can
travel far and through buildings and trees.
In the wireless industry, three-quarters of low-frequency spectrum is in
the hands of AT&T and Verizon, giving those companies a major
competitive advantage and leaving T-Mobile, Sprint and other smaller
phone carriers struggling to deliver reliable service and expand their
networks.
Recognizing that, the federal government is seeking to redistribute
low-frequency spectrum from local TV stations — who claimed significant
swaths of that desirable spectrum in the days before cellphones existed
— to wireless phone carriers.
The Federal Communications Commission is planning to buy spectrum from
TV stations and auction it off to phone carriers, a complicated exchange
that is expected early next year.
The F.C.C. plans to set aside some of the prized resource for smaller
carriers, who have said they cannot afford to bid against AT&T and
Verizon. But just how much spectrum is carved out for those smaller
carriers, and just how deeply it is discounted, has been a major point
of contention.
The questions surrounding the auction may be partly motivating T-Mobile
to engage in merger negotiations. Dish Network has amassed a large
amount of spectrum in recent years, to the puzzlement of many in the
industry, with analysts left wondering what the satellite provider’s
plan for that resource was.
“T-Mobile is holding on by a thread,” said Ellen Satterwhite, a former
F.C.C. employee and director of Glen Echo Group, a strategic
communications firm focused on technology and telecommunications issues.
“And if the F.C.C. isn’t going to make enough low-band spectrum
available, I can see the agency offering approval of this merger as a
chew toy to advocates for competition.”
But much of Dish’s spectrum is mid-frequency spectrum, not low, meaning
it cannot travel as far but has the capacity to carry more information.
“It doesn’t stand to reason for me that a T-Mobile-Dish merger would
mean immediate competition,” Ms. Satterwhite said. “How do you use that
mid-band spectrum to get the kind of coverage you need to compete with
AT&T and Verizon?”
Still, some have suggested that as technology evolves, the value of
various types of spectrum might change, perhaps making Dish’s mid-band
spectrum, with its capacity to carry more data, more valuable to
carriers like T-Mobile.
Craig Moffett, senior analyst and partner at MoffettNathanson Research,
called low-frequency spectrum critically important for offering service
in rural areas. But, he said, it is less important in urban areas, where
signals do not have to travel as far. And in a world in which phones are
regularly used for Internet access, the ability to transport more
information over shorter distances might prove increasingly important.
“There’s a legitimate debate now over what’s most valuable,” Mr. Moffett
said. “It may have been true once upon a time, in the world of voice,
that low-frequency was the best. But in the world of data, higher
frequency may be just as good.”
--
=================================================
George Antunes Voice (713) 743-3923
Associate Professor Fax (713) 743-3927
Political Science Mail: antunes at uh dot edu
University of Houston
Houston, TX 77204-3011
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net