Smartphones dial up OT headaches
After-hours calls, emails may be the norm, but litigation is a risk
By Alexia Elejalde-Ruiz | Chicago Tribune
Jeffrey Allen answered his work BlackBerry during Thanksgiving
dinner, during his son’s soccer match, on any number of Saturday afternoons.
The phone would buzz with work-related texts, emails and calls from
the time he woke until he headed to bed — and, with it always in reach,
he would respond.
“I just saw it as part of the job,” said Allen, 51, a Chicago police
sergeant.
But it was not a part of the job he was paid for, Allen alleges in a
class-action lawsuit against the city of Chicago filed five years ago
that heads to trial next month. He and about 50 officers who have joined
the suit seek overtime pay for off-duty hours spent monitoring and
responding to work emails and phone calls on their company-issued mobile
devices.
Anyone familiar with the ping of a late-night email, a weekend call
from a boss or a mid-dinner glance at a text message has felt the
inescapability of work in the age of smartphones. But while constant
connectedness has become the norm, it has also become a source of
overtime litigation — and attorneys say that could increase under a
proposal from the Obama administration to make millions more salaried
Americans eligible for overtime, including many in managerial positions.
“As managers, they are more likely to be checking in during off
hours,” said Phillip Schreiber, a Chicago-based employment lawyer at
Holland & Knight who represents businesses and is not involved in the
police suit.
The new overtime rule proposed by the Labor Department last month
would raise to $50,440 the minimum salary an employee must make before
they can be classified as exempt from overtime, up from $23,660
currently. The government estimates that would extend overtime pay to
nearly 5 million salaried workers in a range of professions, from store
managers to staff accountants, who currently are exempt under “white
collar” provisions. The salary threshold doesn’t affect certain workers,
including teachers, outside sales representatives and certain hourly
computer professionals.
More overtime-eligible workers means greater risk of litigation and
greater need for employers to establish clear policies mandating that
such employees not field work-related communication on their mobile
devices when they’re off the clock, unless they’re authorized by a
supervisor, Schreiber said.
“In addition to having a policy, you have to have training,”
Schreiber said. “And you don’t penalize employees who don’t respond to
emails or texts off hours, because they’re not supposed to.”
In response to overtime concerns, the Labor Department plans to seek
public comment next month on the use of smartphones to work off hours,
and it could subsequently propose a new rule or guidance on the topic.
Under the Fair Labor Standards Act, employers are responsible for
paying overtime when they know or should know that an employee is
working after hours, even if the employee does not say so or file an
overtime claim. Some obvious clues: a late-night email from a daytime
employee or a project that was unfinished at the end of the day Friday
that turns up finished first thing Monday. Time stamps make it difficult
to not know.
Some employees may prefer to work off the clock because that’s their
work style or they want to impress or get ahead. Millennials in
particular, who rarely part from their phones, may find it difficult to
resist the reflexive tendency to check and respond as emails come in,
said Brad Karsh, CEO and founder of Chicago-based JB Training Solutions,
an employee development company.
“They’re very goal-oriented: Getting through my emails at 10 tonight
makes my day tomorrow easier,” Karsh said.
Yet even if employees are working during off-hours voluntarily and
seemingly enthusiastically, employers shouldn’t trust that they won’t
sue down the road, said Douglas Hass, a Chicago-based employment lawyer
with Franczek Radelet P.C. who represents management in compensation
cases. When people get fired, or angry, or fall into financial hardship,
they can quickly change their tune.
“You could end up losing the business over not making those kinds of
arrangements,” Hass said. “Once you’re supporting multiple people, it’s
not a smart risk.”
Allen’s case could be a cautionary tale for employers. Allen felt he
had found his calling when he was assigned to supervise a money
laundering team in the Chicago Police Department’s Bureau of Organized
Crime. He didn’t mind the extra hours he put in on his company-issued
Black-Berry because it was a prestigious post with opportunity for
promotion, and he was driven to succeed, he said.
An hourly employee, he was eligible for overtime but never filed for
it in relation to BlackBerry use, as it was implicitly understood in the
unit that that wasn’t done, he said.
But when Allen was transferred from the bureau to a district job
with lesser status, the payoff of prestige and potential career
advancement that motivated him to be available at all times evaporated,
he said. His attorneys have calculated, based on his phone records, that
during one 28-day period he spent 720 minutes, or 12 hours, on his
BlackBerry on off-duty work-related phone calls. That doesn’t include
time spent on emails.
“I could not have done the seizures or the work I did without the
Black-Berry,” said Allen, who is now a tactical sergeant in the Austin
police district. “But I need to be compensated now for the time that I
put in because the consideration that I was intending them to give me
was taken away from me.”
One of his attorneys, Paul Geiger, said the case is simply about
paying officers for the work they do.
“The ones in the elite units are absolutely expected to work part of
the time for free, and that’s illegal,” Geiger said.
The city’s Law Department said it is inappropriate for it to comment
on the specifics of active litigation. But in general, “the city
believes this suit is without merit and that the Chicago Police
Department has an established and utilized process for officers to
request and receive overtime compensation,” spokesman John Holden said.
The Police Department had no written policy on off-duty BlackBerry
use when the lawsuit was filed in May 2010, Geiger said, but it
published one a few months later that stated employees were not
obligated to carry their devices or respond to them while off-duty. An
updated policy issued in 2013 states employees are not to use their
devices while off-duty at all unless a supervisor directs them to
perform work immediately and authorizes overtime pay for it.
The lawsuit heads to a bench trial Aug. 17.
Because many such cases were settled, getting a judgment could mean
Allen v. Chicago sets a precedent for overtime lawsuits related to
smartphones, said Laura Bacon, a Chicago-based employment lawyer with
Nixon Peabody focused on advising clients on commercial litigation and
labor issues.
Bacon recommends companies get in front of the issue with written
policies to which employees must consent, given the expense of defending
against such suits.
The emphasis on overtime vigilance comes as employees also
increasingly seek flexible work arrangements, which often rely on
smartphones for working remotely — time that can be difficult to
accurately record, Bacon said.
That’s not to say every glance at the work phone rings up a bill.
Some off-duty actions, like taking 30 seconds to scan a two-line email
or a minute to answer a phone call, can be deemed so trivial that a
court won’t consider it, Hass said.
But taking 10 minutes to read a memo can be overtime-worthy, and if
the boss is one to pepper you with 40 short emails in a day, it can add
up, Hass said. Employers have to figure out how to track employees’
smartphone usage when they’re not on the clock so that they can
compensate them appropriately, he said.
“It’s naive to think no one is going to check their email after
work,” Hass said.
Companies’ overtime policies also should include a disciplinary
component so that there are consequences, like lost privileges, if
employees consistently work overtime without authorization, Hass said.
Employers could pull back company-issued smartphones or cut back
remote working arrangements if they feel they can’t adequately monitor
their time — and some might limit remote access to remove the temptation
altogether, Hass said.
In 2011, Volkswagen cut off corporate email between 6:15 p.m. and 7
a.m. for 4,000 employees in Germany. Director of communications Carsten
Krebs said it has been “a huge success.”
“The employees are very happy with the new policy,” Krebs said.
“They can spend more time with their families, they like the new
work-life balance.”
But Kelly Goldsmith, assistant professor of marketing at
Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management, believes the
solution lies not in technology but in a company’s culture.
“If you really want to shut down the workaholics, you have to do it
firm-wide by setting that example,” she said.
At JB Training, Karsh tries to instill that culture at his office.
He said he tells his employees that he may send them emails at weird
hours because it fits with his schedule, but they are not expected to
check or respond to emails once they leave work.
Usually, he said, people don’t need to monitor their email but want
to, perhaps out of curiosity, or boredom, or it gives them a feeling of
worth.
Karsh, who employs some salaried workers who earn less than $50,000
and therefore could qualify for overtime under the Labor Department
proposal, said he may institute a formal policy on after-hours
smart-phone use if the rule is adopted. He doubts people can break the
smartphone habit on their own.
“We can’t separate work and life,” he said. “If it’s going to
happen, it has to be mandated.” [email protected]
--
*================================================ Duane Whittingham -
N9SSN (ARES/RACES, EmComm, Skywarn & Red Cross) (Melrose Park Public
Safety & Homeland Security) http://www.mpdes.org
http://www.radiodude.info ================================================*
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net