Patrolling the darkest part of the Web
A team of agents tasked with protecting Obama must sift through hateful
online comments to find would-be assassins or terrorists
By Josephine Wolff The Atlantic
When President Barack Obama launched his Twitter account in May,
people noticed his rapid accumulation of followers, a silly
back-and-forth with President Clinton, but also something more serious:
the number of hostile and threatening messages directed at the president.
Sifting through those messages to determine which, if any, need to
be taken seriously is the responsibility of the Secret Service Internet
Threat Desk, a group of agents tasked with identifying and assessing
online threats to the president and his family. The first part of this
mission — finding threats — is in many ways made easier by the Internet:
all you have to do is search! Pulling up every tweet that uses the words
“Obama” and “assassinate” takes mere seconds, and the Secret Service has
tried to make it easier for people to draw threats to its attention by
setting up its own Twitter handle, @secretservice, for users to report
threatening messages to.
But if the Internet makes it easier to find threats directed at the
president, it can also make it harder to figure out which ones should be
taken seriously. The sheer volume of threatening messages online, the
lack of context and the ease with which users can shield their
identities all contribute to the challenges of assessing online threats.
One series of tweets addressed to @POTUS that caught the Secret
Service’s attention — at least enough to warrant an in-person visit from
an agent — came from a user with the handle @jeffgully49 and included a
picture showing a doctored version of the president’s campaign posters
with his head in a noose and the word “HOPE” changed to “ROPE.” The
messages were apparently posted by Jeff Gullickson of Plymouth, Minn.,
who was later visited at his home by a Secret Service agent. “The agent
from the Secret Service was cordial,” Gullickson wrote in an email to
MPR News, adding that the agent just wanted to be sure his tweets were
not serious threats.
Making sure that Gullickson was not a threat required more than just
an analysis of his online comments
— it called for offline contact, an in-person visit, an assessment
of who he was and what he was like face-to-face, not just on the
Internet. Context is crucial for evaluating the seriousness of threats —
both digital and analog — but online threats offer a slightly different
set of contextual clues than their offline counterparts. And while much
of the hate-filled commentary on the Internet is routinely written off
as hyperbole and ranting, threats directed at the president are not so
easily dismissed. So, every day, the Secret Service Internet Threat Desk
is faced with the unenviable task of taking seriously some of the most
extreme online rhetoric and trying to identify potential assassins or
terrorists in the deluge of venomous messages directed at the president
and his family.
Though most of the public cases involving the Internet threat desk
have to do with threats made via Twitter or Facebook, the desk actually
predates both platforms. Founded in 2000, the desk was reportedly
expanded in 2009 around the same time that threats against Obama spiked
in the early months of his first term. Ronald Kessler, author of “In the
President’s Secret Service,” said that when he visited the Internet
threat desk several years ago it was “just a small room with a few
people,” but added, “I’m sure it’s much bigger now.” Secret Service
spokesman Robert Hoback declined to comment.
Since the Internet threat desk’s founding, Kessler said, more of the
threats the Secret Service assesses have originated online, but the
overall number of threats directed at the first family that require
investigation has stayed relatively steady at about 10 per day — except
for the period when Obama was first elected, when the Secret Service had
to follow up on roughly 50 threats per day. “That includes threats on
Twitter,” Kessler said. “It makes no difference to [the Secret Service]
how a threat is communicated,” he added. “They can’t take that chance of
assuming that because it’s on Twitter it’s less serious.”
The Secret Service categorizes all threats, online and offline
alike, into one of three categories, according to Kessler. Class 3
threats are considered the most serious and require agents to interview
the individual who issued the threat and any acquaintances to determine
whether that person really has the capability to carry out the threat.
Class 2 threats are considered to be serious but issued by people
incapable of actually follow up on their intentions, either because they
are in jail or located at a great distance from the president. And Class
1 threats are those that may seem serious at first, but are determined
not to be.
Classifying threats into these categories is partly a matter of
wording and specificity—whether the speaker has developed a detailed
plan, whether they state that they will kill the president or just that
someone should kill the president—but also depends largely on the
background of the people who issue them. “The Secret Service looks at
whether this person has expressed similar plans previously, whether this
person has a criminal record, or is mentally ill,” Kessler said.
Presumably, that’s why an agent showed up at Gullickson’s house — to
assess the person who issued the Twitter threat, not just the threat itself.
But the Secret Service can’t very well interview everyone who
directs hostile comments at the president online — there are just too
many of them — especially as the government’s embrace of social media
platforms creates an increasing number of channels for lashing out at
the president. “What you’ve done with the POTUS Twitter account is
created a one-stop shopping for people who don’t like the president to
blow off steam and convey their view that they don’t like the
president,” said University of Maryland law professor Danielle Citron.
“That could perfectly well be political protest: ‘I hate you and I want
to throw you in the river’ could mean ‘I hate your ideas and want to
throw them in the river,’ or it could mean ‘I’m a neo-Nazi and I want to
kill you because you’re a black president.’ For the president, [the
Secret Service] is going to err on the side of over-inclusion and more
false positives.”
Paring down those false positives may be even more of a challenge
online than off. The Internet threat desk “comb[s] the internet” and has
people “working 24 hours a day just going through the Internet looking
for any type of buzzwords or any type of threatening or inappropriate
activity out there that we may see that involves any of our protectees,”
Sullivan said at the 2011 hearing.
In other words, the Secret Service is actively seeking out threats
made online, rather than waiting for others to report them, or for the
people issuing threats to contact the White House directly. “Online
threats are much more findable — I can set up some structured queries
and find out who’s making threats in real time,” said Andy Sellars, a
fellow at Harvard’s Berkman Center for Internet & Society. “You can
essentially have a column on TweetDeck for every time someone says
‘president’ and ‘kill’ in the same tweet. A lot of tools being sold to
law enforcement are basically just glorified versions of Tweet-Deck.”
Finding the threats is the easy part, though. “It’s a lot easier to
figure out the context of speech in the physical world than in the
online world,” said Hanni Fakhoury, a senior staff attorney at the
Electronic Frontier Foundation. “You need that context in order to see
what that speech really means.”
The cases that the Secret Service has pursued in recent years offer
some clues as to which types of threats they seem to take most
seriously. Repeat offenders, unsurprisingly, seem to come in for
particular attention. For instance, Jarvis Britton of Birmingham, Ala.,
was arrested and sentenced to a year in prison in 2013 after posting a
series of tweets over the course of several months. In a 2012 affidavit,
Secret Service Special Agent Phillip Holly described the series of
events that led up to Britton’s arrest, beginning with two tweets on
June 28, 2012, that read: “Free speech? Really? Let’s test this! Let’s
kill the president!” and “I’m going to finish this, if they get me, they
get me! #ohwell. I think we could get the president with cyanide.
#MakeIt-Slow.” The next day, Britton tweeted “Barack Obama, I wish you
were DEAD!”
Following the June tweets, the Secret Service spoke with Britton and
advised him of “the seriousness of the matter,” according to Holly, but
“no further action was taken” until Britton resumed tweeting threats
several months later. On Sept. 14, 2012, he posted the message “Let’s
kill the president. F.E.A.R.” After learning of the September threats
from the Internet Threat Desk, Holly concludes: “Based upon the
foregoing, I have probable cause to believe that Jarvis
M. Britton did knowingly and willfully threaten to take the life of,
kidnap, or inflict bodily harm upon the President of the United States.”
Donte Jamar Sims of Charlotte, N.C., was also sentenced in 2013 to
serve jail time for a series of threatening tweets directed at the
president. Sims’ tweets, posted during the 2012 Democratic National
Convention, included the messages: “Ima Assassinate president Obama this
evening!” and “The Secret Service is gonna be defenseless once I aim the
Assault Rifle at Barack’s Forehead.”
The Internet Threat Desk’s investigations are not limited to
Twitter. One 2012 investigation centered on a Facebook photo of several
young men from Arizona posing with guns and a T-shirt with the
president’s face on it riddled with bullet holes. A 2008 case focused on
a series of pseudonymous comments made by the user californiaradial on
the Yahoo Finance website, including “Shoot the nig. Country fkd for
another 4 years+, what nig has done ANYTHING right???? Long term????
Never in history, except sambos.” And “Fk the niggar, he will have a 50
cal in the head soon.” In court documents, Special Agent Gregory Becker
identified californiaradial as Walter Edward Bagdasarian after the
Internet Threat Desk “obtained the IP address from which the messages
had been sent, as well as the subscriber information for that account.”
When people who issue online threats are identified, they sometimes
try to provide context for those threats that might excuse their
behavior. Sims, for instance, claimed he was high on marijuana when he
threatened the president. Britton’s lawyer similarly insisted his client
had no intentions to actually harm the president. Other times, the real
world context of online threats makes them seem more concerning — when
the Secret Service searched Bagdasarian’s house, they found a .50
caliber rifle among his possessions, which appeared to lend credence to
the prediction “he will have a 50 cal in the head soon.”
Ultimately, however, it is the content of the threat itself — not
the context — that seems to matter most in court. Sims, Britton, and
Bagdasarian all allegedly issued multiple violent threats at the
president in online forums. But Sims and Britton were sent to jail,
regardless of the claims both made about their respective mental states
when they issued the threats
— while Bagdasarian’s conviction was ultimately reversed by a
federal appeals court in California because he had not specifically said
that he himself would kill the president but, rather, suggested more
generally that someone should do so.
The Supreme Court has avoided establishing any clear line between
true threats and free speech on the Internet.
Making these distinctions between the people who really intended
harm — the people who, in legal language, issued threats that they
should have reasonably foreseen would be interpreted as “serious
expressions of intent to inflict bodily harm upon that person” — and the
people who were merely venting political frustrations or indulging in
some hyperbolic anger is a very murky area of law, particularly when it
comes to online threats. “It is harder to separate the wheat from the
chaff online,” said Fakhoury, the Electronic Frontier Foundation lawyer,
of distinguishing “true threats” from speech that is protected by the
First Amendment. “Part of that is the speed with which people can
communicate online, part of it is that people are somewhat removed from
what they say online, part of it is the breadth of the audience that
exists online,” he explained.
The ease with which anyone can fire off a threat to the president’s
Twitter account does not necessarily make such threats less concerning,
Citron noted. “Sometimes people say online threats are never to be taken
seriously because we’re behind a screen and we tend to just kind of
mouth off without thinking, but on the other hand when someone writes
something down then there’s the perception that its thoughtful—someone
took the time to write this down,” she said.
“The anonymous part doesn’t make it less threatening, but it makes
it harder for us to gauge whether it’s a joke or not.” +
--
*================================================ Duane Whittingham -
N9SSN (ARES/RACES, EmComm, Skywarn & Red Cross) (Melrose Park Public
Safety & Homeland Security) http://www.mpdes.org
http://www.radiodude.info ================================================*
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net