My 2 cents on the Pluto planet/planetoid debate:
 
There is one commonality shared by Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Jupiter,
Saturn, Uranus and Neptune -- and NO other known solar system bodies.
They each represent more than 50% of the total mass of all other bodies
in a similar orbit.  Note that Ceres would not be part of this group -- it is
not more massive than the sum of all other asteroids in a similar orbit.
Pluto, likewise, would not meet this requirement -- like Ceres, it is the
largest body in its type of orbit, but the sum of the masses of all other
bodies in similar orbits exceeds that of Pluto.
 
The nice thing about this definition is that it is simple and unambiguous.
 
--Rob
 

Reply via email to