If you are advocating for a clean-up of the requirements, I am 100% in agreement, but it seems to me that you are advancing a complete misrepresentation of the BBF requirement. Since we already agree that the requirements need clean-up, talking about how one requirement indicates a problem with another is moot—let's just advocate a careful review and cleanup, and see if the authors will do that. If not, there is no way to make forward progress, and in that case it would make the most sense to just discontinue the work.
But assuming the authors are willing to clean up the requirements, it would be better to postpone discussion of the problems with the requirements section until that work has been done. _______________________________________________ mif mailing list mif@ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mif
