Folks, to be fair there was a request for a review into the mailing list, the poster was transparent it was AI, Fair, I dont think the OP intended to demand anyone specifically to review the code.
but we all do have to be mindful of human developers time, and as a dear friend called "some LLM outputs a wall of text" it is mentally draining... that is Fair. my personal view is that any AI that is posted had better been tested by a person and reviewed as thoroughly as the ability of the person proposing it can give... I have used AI tools (with very mixed results (albeit improving) but before posting anything review it test it... there are a lot of volunteers on this project and their time is valuable... there are only so many skilled developers who can fully understand the code and its implications to the project and its community...it is important not to overwhelm them (even if well intentioned) ... (mae culpa) sorry On Sat, 14 Nov 2026 at 22:59, Rudolf Leitgeb <[email protected]> wrote: > > You make a big issue about how this software is being written. Nobody > asked you personally to do anything with this software, and since you > are likely unfamiliar with AI driven software development, your input > would not be as helpful as you think it is. > > None of this invalidates my ask for the AI input to generate this code, > which seems to be the actual brain child of the original poster. > > And it would also allow us to judge quickly, whether this is vibe > coded slop "write me an IMAP server, here are the RFCs", or whether > some delicate design effort went into this. > > At this point we just don't know. > > On Sat, 2026-11-14 at 17:42 -0500, brad wrote: > > > > It's insulting to ask others to spend time reading software that you > > did > > not spend time writing and software that you, yourself do not > > understand. > > > > If you like the software that AI wrote for you, use it. But don't > > expect > > others to spend time carefully reading and reviewing it for you. It's > > rude and out of touch to ask for this. > > > > Brad > -- Kindest regards, Tom Smyth.

