Hi Marco,

> I know about IMG resolution, Mark. That is the reason I think there is a bug. 
> If the Garmin cannot handle such short arcs, mkgmap shall compile the case in 
> a way that does not violate the garmin specs.

It would be nice if mkgmap could work around the problem of short arcs
so I am looking into what it needs to do to achieve that.
Unfortunately, it's not an easy problem to solve so it will take a
little thought.

> But I'm not really sure that the problem is exactly this. It might be that 
> mkgmap has a bug in the routing data base compiling. Well I'm not expert, but 
> I guess something goes wrong when the 2 so close nodes collapses in a single 
> node when the garmin encoding is applied. Then 2 nodes in OSM, 1 node in 
> Garmin... and the routing DB gets corrupted. Something like that (but I'm 
> really speculating).

The nodes are separate, just too close together.
 
> Someone should check the code to track the situation. The osm file I've 
> attached (that reproduce the error) is small enough to be tested carefully.

Thanks for the sample.

Cheers,

Mark
_______________________________________________
mkgmap-dev mailing list
[email protected]
http://www.mkgmap.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/mkgmap-dev

Reply via email to