Thank you both for all your advice and knowledge! Lydia Irons
On Thursday, July 10, 2025 at 12:48:14 AM UTC-7 Paolo Piras wrote: > Hi Andrea and Lydia > just a word about "In the first case, however, CS is just rounding > error (1.00001, 0.9999 > and the like)". It's a while I don't use MorphoJ but I think that > after GPA rotation with scaling at unit CS (thus "1" precisely) it > projects data orthogonally [I dont think it does it stereo > graphically] from the (hemi-) sphere [I suspect it does not scale at > 1/cos(rho), i.e. Kendall's sphere sensu stricto] onto the tangent > plane to the consensus; CS of shapes lying on the (hemi-) sphere is > always actually 1, i.e. the sphere's radius by definition, but CS of > projected data is the vector length from the (hemi-) sphere center and > the point on the tangent plane; thus it is impossible to have CS > values smaller than 1: all the values should exceed 1 by a small > quantity but they should never be smaller nor exactly 1. Only the > consensus will have 1 as it lies concomitantly on the sphere and on > the tangent plane by definition. > Not sure, however, about fine details in MorphoJ procedure. > > All the best > Paolo > > > > Il giorno gio 10 lug 2025 alle ore 09:33 andrea cardini > <[email protected]> ha scritto: > > > > Dear Lydia, > > I read quickly but the steps you wrote seem correct to me. Most of them > > are also summarized in the guidelines I wrote a while ago: > > https://europeanjournaloftaxonomy.eu/index.php/ejt/issue/view/1425 > > In the papers, you'll find some caveats about the statistical analyses > > and visualization of superimposed data and the references to the papers > > covering those issues. > > > > I've not used CoordGen8 for ages and can't remember what it does > precisely. > > However, before importing the data in MorphoJ, I suggest you to rescale > > the objects to their original centroid size (CS). Otherwise, that > > information is lost in MorphoJ unless you import CS as a covariate. Be > > careful, because MorphoJ (after redoing the superimposition) will show > > you a CS variable regardless of whether you imported shape or form data. > > In the first case, however, CS is just rounding error (1.00001, 0.9999 > > and the like). If you import form (i.e., rescaled superimposed data), > > that's not an issue and you have the correct CS. Most of the time, you > > want to analyze both shape, size and maybe allometry. > > Rescaling is trivial: in xls, multiply each shape coordinates for the > > corresponding CS. Alternatively, if you use TPSRelw, there should be an > > option for rescaling. It used to be called "restore size" (more or less) > > but possibly now it's Boas coordinates. Jim will correct me. I am not > > sure and cannot check now, as I have a beta version installed which is a > > bit different. > > > > Good luck with the analysis! > > Cheers > > > > Andrea PS I think there's a later version of MorphoJ now. > > > > > > On 09/07/2025 20:12, 'Lydia Irons' via Morphmet wrote: > > > Hi, > > > > > > I’d like some input on whether I’m using various geometric morphometric > > > programs correctly or not. I’m a research technician working on a > geometric > > > morphometric project on seed beetles, and I’ve mainly taught myself > how to > > > use all these programs by reading various handbooks and such. Since > there > > > are a lot of steps, I want to make sure I’m not missing anything or > doing > > > something incorrectly. Here’s how I’ve been doing it, starting from > placing > > > landmarks all the way to running statistical analyses: > > > > > > 1. I use tpsUtil32 to create a tps file of all the photos I want to > > > landmark using the “Build tps file from images” operation. I hit > “Input” > > > and choose an image file from the folder where all my images are, then > I > > > hit “Output” and create a name for the tps file. I then select “Setup” > and > > > include all the images I need, then hit “ok” > > > 2. Then I upload this file to tpsDig264 and place the landmarks first, > then > > > the semilandmarks, for each specimen. I use the “Digitize landmarks” > tool > > > for landmarks, and the “Draw background curves” tool for > semilandmarks. I > > > make sure every specimen has the same number of landmarks and > > > semilandmarks, using the “Resample curve” option to keep the number of > > > semilandmarks consistent for each curve > > > 3. Once I’m done landmarking, I open the tps file using Notepad and > change > > > the number after “ID=” to the unique specimen IDs I’ve given to each > > > specimen > > > 4. Then I use CoordGen8 and upload the tps file using the “load tps, > > > convert curves, create SLM proto” option. I save the protocol file, > then do > > > a “SemiLandMark Alignment” and upload the protocol file to align all > the > > > landmarks and semilandmarks. Then I hit “save all” > > > 5. The resulting file then has to be formatted for MorphoJ, which > involves > > > adding the specimen IDs to the beginning of each block of coordinates > that > > > corresponds to that specimen, deleting the centroid size at the end of > each > > > block of coordinates, making sure a paragraph mark separates each > > > specimen’s block of coordinates, and adding a comma followed by a space > > > between every number > > > 6. Once the formatting is done, I upload this file to MorphoJ 1.07a by > > > selecting “create new dataset” and selecting the data as 2 dimensions, > > > selecting “yes” for object symmetry if applicable, and choosing the > file > > > type as “text.” Then I click “new procrustes fit” and line up the > landmarks > > > if there is object symmetry. I look for any outliers, generate a > covariance > > > matrix, extract classifiers from my specimen ID, and run whatever > analyses > > > I need to (PCA, CVA, ANOVA, etc.) > > > > > > Are there any steps I’m missing or things I’m doing incorrectly? > > > > > > Thank you in advance, > > > Lydia Irons > > > > > > > -- > > Andrea Cardini > > E-mail address: [email protected], [email protected] > > WEBPAGE: https://sites.google.com/view/alcardini2/ > > > > -- > > You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google > Groups "Morphmet" group. > > To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send > an email to [email protected]. > > To view this discussion visit > https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/morphmet2/cb16dbac-a966-435a-a1c9-6f1ed43f8267%40gmail.com > . > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Morphmet" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/morphmet2/03a01ae2-edb1-4adf-a678-9f76f0682781n%40googlegroups.com.
