Please do not attempt to confuse the issue of a Motel on Lake Street with the
idea that investment of $6 million is automatically a good thing. All
investment has a price tag, all investment, however, is not necessarily good for
the community. The proposal by ArtSpace for the same space that Basim wants to
build his motel would have cost at least as much if not more; that would imply
that it is automatically better if it costs more. We all know better than that!
The design of the proposed development may or may not be favorable. While good
design is important, (for any development) it is ultimatly the land use that is
the primary issue. Are you familiar with the Fair Oaks Motel in the Whittier
neighborhood? The Fair Oaks was a problem for 20 years and has finally been
removed. Don't forget that there are still more than a few "saunas" on east
Lake - the area has improved in the last several years, but is in no way
prepared for what a motel could mean. While the investors believe they will
capture part of the downtown hotel market, what happens when they don't?
Suddenly they have a $6 million investment that has to be paid for, somehow.
Mansoor & his family do not want to live adjacent to a hotel and have made this
clear more than once. They do, however, feel very helpless to stop it being as
new to the country as they are, and feel threatened by the process.
Talk to any of the area residents, and you will get a similar response of
disapproval - the two houses south of the proposed development that you noted
are owned by Dave Coral (3037) and Corrine Zala (3045) ; both have made
significant investments in their properties and are committed to the
neighborhood. one the other side of that block, the houses that face 3rd Avenue
don't support it either - Ken Flowers and his family are facing increasing
pressure to sell their house to Basam for a parking lot, the Lors sold to Basim
after they received written death threats from an anonymous source, and Brad
Otto opposes it.
You mentioned speaking with Brian at 3145 2nd, and implied that they support the
development. While they may have indicated that the design proposed was not
objectionable per say, I can assure you that they do oppose the land use of
motel so please don't misrepresent their position. In fact, they were appalled
when I told them you were claiming they support the concept of a motel.
How many times have I heard Basim telling everyone that everybody supports
whatever it is he is doing at the moment! It's part of a strategy to build an
impression of widespread support for issues that are questionable at best. As
far as getting the feeling that Basim is "pulling one over on you", he did!
Basim managed to aquire the land for the motel by convincing everyone he was
purchasing it to secure it for the ArtSpace proposal. There are other similar
examples that are too numerous to get into. I don't want to denigrate Basim,
though, as he is not the issue either - the issue is the land-use.
Finally, the proposed location definatly needs development and investment; that
is no reason to support this development. There are other development
opportunities that are more suitable and enhance liveability in the
neighborhood, such as the ArtSpace proposal. The ArtSpace proposal would not
only develop the space (including the Round Up building), but would also provide
30 units of affordable housing in an area where so much has been demolished
amidst the housing shortage. I can think of at least 3 other existing proposals
for the space as well. Fact is the area does not want a Motel, and has voted
down similar proposals for motels consistently (usually proposed by Urban
Ventures).
If a motel is desirable, then why not put it where it will not require variances
and will not impact adjacent residential properties?? Just across the freeway
would accomodate, and the "displaced" offices and businesses could be
accomodated on 2nd Avenue if not elsewhere along Lake.
timothy connolly <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> on 03/17/2001 05:46:20 PM
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
cc: (bcc: Dave G Piehl/USA/Pillsbury)
Subject: [Mpls] Re: East Lake motel
I read a couple posts on this subject earlier in the
week but got caught up in hearings at the capitol and
knowing not enough but interested i wanted to survey
the scene before i weighed in.
one of the problems for me ia i've been confused as to
what goes on in central. i know or have met a few of
the players and i have no desire to wade into that
morass with these comments. i know there is history
and bad blood all around. let me speak solely to the
issue of the proposed hotel.
First a disclaimer. I know Basim Sabri fairly well. I
want to say quite well but that might imply we have
socialized in the past, something i would not mind
doing, would even enjoy, doing in the future.
I first met Basim years ago and i'm sure even he does
not recall the circumstances. I was a waiter at The
Lotus rest. in Uptown and Basim and his brothers were
frequent patrons. They were wild; my first inclination
was to distance myself. More recently I have come to
embrace him.
Basim sometimes I think has played a little hard and
fast with the rules though never I believe in any
malicious or evil way. You have to understand the ways
of the Middle East I think to truly understand him and
especially the people who think of themselves as
Palestinians. It's always a little hard to keep up
with him and it's easy to get the feeling he might be
pulling one over on you. Believe me I've feared as
much myself.
But enough of Basim.
I walked this afternoon around the blocks from Lake to
32nd and from 2nd to 3rd avenues after running into
Basim at the 8th ward convention. I asked him "what's
up with this hotel?" He gave me his thumbnail sketch
and I took it from there.
There are no trees on the six lots where he proposes
to build save two, i recall, scrawny ones of little
aesthetic value. The Roundup building, though no great
shakes right now has potential but only if development
happens behind it. Across the alley from Basim's six
lots are three multiple dwelings in disrepair and with
unshoveled walks. One structure looks like it has been
worked on. South on third is a boarded apartment
building appearing to have eight units on two floors
and four at "garden level".
At the south end of the block on the alley lives a
nice man named Mansoor and his sister and
brother-in-law I believe. I talked a bit with him.
When I asked what he thougt about a hotel his first
reaction was to dislike the idea. Then as we talked he
began to wonder if the value of the house would
appreciate. I said yes but then so would property
taxes. I told him I thought a hotel may improve the
neighborhood/block.
On Second Av just south of the proposed development
are two or three houses, one in the process right now
of being rehabbed.
What can I say about the Healy Block that has not
already been said or written. I did happen to talk to
two men who recently purchased the house on the corner
of 2nd and 32nd. Street. One's name was Brian; the
other I sadly have forgotten. They are open to the
idea of a Hotel. Italked with them. I told them it
might be a good thing. I also talked about Basim from
my perspective.
It was their impression that the design of the hotel
would be nice looking. Now we can argue about what is
nice looking and people could say any motor hotel as
we use to call them is inherently ugly. This one will
have 67 units with first floor retail I'm told.
All in all I believe it might not be just a good thing
for that block and neighborhood but a great thing.
First off these people are talking about a minimum $6
million investment. Nobody investing that kind of
money wants to live in a declining neighborhood. They
will be a catalyst.
They need a zoning variance to go ahead with the
project. If I lived in Central and was a part of CNIA
you can bet your last dollar I would be talking to
them. I think as a part of the deal the neighborhood
ought to figure out a way to rehab some properties
including the boarded up apartment house and get some
good affordable housing run on a non-profit basis
There's a way to do something good here and I believe
it should be explored.
Enough for now. Running out of time at the library and
I want to post today.
Let's talk more
Tim Connolly
Ward 7
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Get email at your own domain with Yahoo! Mail.
http://personal.mail.yahoo.com/
_______________________________________________
Minneapolis Issues Forum - Minnesota E-Democracy
Post messages to: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subscribe, Unsubscribe, Digest option, and more:
http://e-democracy.org/mpls
______________________________________________________________________
The information contained in this message is private and confidential
information which may also be subject to the attorney-client privilege and work
product doctrine. This information is intended only for the individual or
entity named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that any use, dissemination, distribution or
copy of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this message
in error, please notify the sender by return e-mail and destroy all copies of
the message. Thank you.
_______________________________________________
Minneapolis Issues Forum - Minnesota E-Democracy
Post messages to: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subscribe, Unsubscribe, Digest option, and more:
http://e-democracy.org/mpls
