On 12/30/19 6:31 PM, Ca By wrote:
> is is still a physics thing. Most purest will says 5G = new radio (NR). NR 
> can run in any band. And, the distance is a function of the band. Tmobile is 
> big on 600mhz NR, Sprint is big on 2500mhz NR and VZW has 28ghz NR. 

Is/are there defined standard(s) for this NR?  I was of the impression that we 
were basically just tweaking the LTE-A MAC and OFDM[A] PHY for wider bandwidth 
(mid-band and mmwave) or newly available low-band (600MHz) spectrum 
deployments.  AFAIK, there's no new PHY tricks going on for "5G" that aren't 
already being used for "4G" LTE-A deployments on existing mainstream spectrum.  
Aside from the new bands, what's the burden on the handset vs. base?  A lot of 
tricks (beamforming, multi-site MIMO, etc.) can be done without real changes to 
the handset, and we can thankfully mostly upgrade the OFDM PHY to support e.g. 
denser modulation constellations in a somewhat incremental manner.

I already see lots of outdoor small cells on fiber in dense retail, academic, 
business, etc. areas even in suburbs.  I assume they're quite common in urban 
areas, though I don't get to do much work in those environments.  Deployment of 
these started well before any 5G hype I was aware of even on the network 
operator side (think 6+ years ago).

All that is to say, what's the magic secret sauce that makes "5G" any real 
different from "modern 4G"?  I really don't want to go diving down the 3GPP 
document hole...
-- 
Brandon Martin

Reply via email to