Justin Shore wrote: > Hank Nussbacher wrote: >> At 18:29 24/11/2009 +0900, Randy Bush wrote: >>> > RIS Routing History for AS1712 since 2001: >>> >>> on what date was AS1712 assigned to the current RIPE holder? >> >> Based on: >> ftp://ftp.ripe.net/pub/stats/ripencc/delegated-ripencc-latest >> it doesn't show AS1712 ever being allocated to Renater (probably why >> the inter-RIR mistake happened) but the surrounding ASNs give you an >> idea of the timeframe: >> >> ripencc|IL|asn|1680|1|19930901|allocated >> ripencc|EU|asn|1707|1|19930901|allocated >> ripencc|EU|asn|1729|1|19930901|allocated >> ripencc|EU|asn|1732|1|19930901|allocated > > Since IANA says that the ASN is ARIN's to assign wouldn't that preclude > another RIR from assigning it?
ARIN didn't exist when those ASN's were assigned, RIPE NCC did. > http://www.iana.org/assignments/as-numbers/ > > Of course if it was already assigned when IANA said that (no dates on > the link above) then maybe the fault is more IANA's for telling another > RIR that they could allocate an ASN that another RIR already allocated. > Who knows. It should be an interesting one to watch play out though. > > Justin > >