>> I'll probably come around, but I've not yet concluded that "screw it, >> fragment my traffic, I don't care" is the stance that a conscientious >> application should be taking. > > Don't you care, for routers, generating ICMP PTB is as burdensome > as generating fragments?
I don't think so. If PMTUD is working (big IF, I know), the ICMP PTB generation is a one-time thing (or once per 10 minutes or whatever) and can be rate limited with little impact. Fragmenting transit traffic, on the other hand, needs to be done for every transit packet.
