Don Cohen wrote:

> There are some tcp options that have to be sent in the syn packet,
> e.g., window scale.  These become unusable if this packet is supplied
> by the firewall, unless the firewall somehow knows how the original
> destination host "would have" answered.  This seems unfortunate, and
> I don't see a good solution.

Not to mention that there is TCP options a firewall cannot know, such as the 
timestamp option.

In my opinion, If you do "syncookie" in a firewall then the TCP should be 
terminated there, with another TCP in to the real server. I.e. a proxy 
solution.

Regards
Henrik Nordström

Reply via email to