----- Original Message -----
> From: "Gene Czarcinski" <g...@czarc.net>
> I will state again that the UUID based on the machine-id does not
> satisfy my need to keep the client-id the same for all installations
> on a system which use a particular interface.

DUID-UUID is currently the most stable mechanism. And stability is the most 
important property of DUID. You can still use manually specified DUID or you 
can use a system script that will rewrite
your DUID file upon system boot to whatever you want.

As this is a very special case, and as it is possible to implement it outside 
NetworkManager, I would prefer a separate implementation. You can simply add 
the call to your script to ExecStartPre, if you are using systemd (find your 
own way for other service managers). Or you could package it as a separate 
service to be run *before* NetworkManager.

> Nope, I still do not understand how to have duid-UUID used.

With the Dan's commit, it should work by default. If not, we have a bug.

> While I can live with manually specifying the default-duid, I would
> still prefer an option where the command-line "-D LL" was used.

I don't think this is much important. I certainly don't want to prevent anyone 
from using any type of DUID. But as it will be stored on-disk anyway, I don't 
see a reason anymore (now that we have machine-id) to risk the stability 
through leaving the generation up to dhclient.

> Well, time to start testing this on real systems so I can give feedback.

Sure.

Cheers,

Pavel
_______________________________________________
networkmanager-list mailing list
networkmanager-list@gnome.org
https://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/networkmanager-list

Reply via email to