On Wednesday 18 May 2005 11:52, Derek Jennings wrote:
>
> That may be how your firewall is configured, but it is not the default.
>
Accepted - I was not trying to argue with what you had said, just trying to 
avoid unnecessary complexity.

> I was trying to emphasise the point that the standard Mandriva firewall
> will block traffic to the local network. Many people get caught out by
> that. The symptoms you get include, being able to see remote printers, or
> Windows computers, but not being able to access them.
>
> The firewall GUI in Mandriva Control Centre does not allow you to
> discriminate between the internet and the local network (major shortcoming
> IMO), you have to use webmin or edit the files by hand to open up the
> ports. Or as you have done to open up the local network entirely.
>
I've never used the gui, so if that is so I agree with you, it is a serious 
shortcoming.

> The firewall issue is something that be-devils newbies trying to network
> Windows and Linux computers so I like to mention it frequently :-)
>
Yes, it's not really what a newbie would expect, is it?  They expect it to be 
blocking external traffic, but not internal traffic - a reasonable 
assumption, but wrong in this case.

Anne
-- 
Registered Linux User No.293302 (http://counter.li.org/)
Have you visited http://twiki.mdklinuxfaq.org yet?  Mandrake at all levels

Attachment: pgpZQ7TpPpqKg.pgp
Description: PGP signature

Reply via email to