Oltre al merito dei suoi ragionamenti (che condivido in toto), notate
come Jill Lepore <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jill_Lepore>, notissima
professoressa a Harvard, critichi pubblicamente le politiche sull'IA del
suo Ateneo, e lo faccia sul "The Harvard Crimson", ovvero, il quotidiano
scritto e diretto dagli studenti di Harvard.
Vengono in mente le parole di un grande storico: "il dissenso è la più
alta forma di patriottismo".
JC
*ARTIFICIAL EDUCATION*
Jill Lepore
16 settembre 2026
https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/9/16/lepore-harvard-artificial-intelligence-education/
This August, an MIT committee of faculty, students, and staff released a
remarkably thoughtful report on “AI Use in Teaching, Learning, and
Research Training.” Its many cautions included the warning that “as a
community, what should worry us most is that many uses of AI deprive
students of the opportunity to learn.”
By contrast, Harvard’s administration appears oblivious to such concerns
— notoriously so. Harvard College Dean David J. Deming’s recent
recommendation
<https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/9/2/deming-ai-use-email/> that
student use of AI in writing-intensive classes should be not only
accepted but encouraged, is only the most outrageous instance. This
policy was, fittingly, the leading example cited in a Chronicle of
Higher Education article titled “The Ivy League’s Surrender to AI Is
Insane.”
Has Harvard indeed lost its mind? The comparison with the MIT report,
set against a growing body of empirical research into the effects of
generative AI on learning, is a good place to start answering that question.
While of course noting the astounding benefits of AI in many areas of
academic research, the MIT report takes careful stock of the ways in
which reliance on AI risks the abandonment of crucial educational
experiences, including the problem set, the take-home exam, office
hours, study groups, and undergraduate research opportunities. In the
latter case, the committee found that instructors were considering
outsourcing research assistance to AI instead of hiring undergraduates,
presumably on the grounds of cost-savings and efficiency. The committee
inquired, “But if those criteria come to dominate our decisions, we all
have to ask, ‘What is it that we are here together to do?’”
Replacing research assistants with bots is a good illustration of the
“Waymo Effect
<https://wonkhe.com/blogs/the-waymo-effect-how-ai-is-quietly-making-research-less-collaborative/>,”
defined by the coiner of the term, Daniel W. Hook, chief scientific
officer at Holtzbrinck Publishing Group, as “what happens when a
technology removes the friction of dealing with another human being, and
we experience that removal as pure gain — because the costs of the
friction were always visible to us, while its benefits were not.”
Getting a ride in a driverless car is convenient and fast, and if you
don’t like talking to a driver or jostling with other people on the bus
or the subway, it’ll seem preferable. But every time you take that ride,
you’re missing out on encountering other people and, over time, you risk
becoming more isolated, and lonelier, and less able to work with other
people or, really, to even handle being with them. “Large language
models,” Hook argues, “are the Waymo of intellectual life.”
At MIT, Harvard, or any other school, supervising an undergraduate
researcher is a lot of work, costs a lot of money, involves a lot of
meetings, and the results are not reliably excellent. Asking Claude is
easier, faster, and may produce better results. It’s also cheaper, which
is no accident: Harvard allows every Harvard student and faculty member
to request a Claude token budget of $2,500 per month, even as research
funding is continuously threatened and the University lays off
<https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/8/21/fas-layoffs-conclude-165-positions/>
staff.
This approach, putting speed and efficiency by way of automation above
all other considerations, comes not from the priorities of intellectual
inquiry or scientific experimentation but from the business models of
corporations. As Hook writes, “The problem is that we have made the
human conversation the expensive option and the machine conversation
free, and we are surprised at what researchers, responding rationally,
then choose.”
But of course, the machine conversation is not free. It comes at the
cost of our common life together as teachers, learners, and researchers,
colleagues, mentors, and friends. Not to mention, supervising student
researchers is our job.
Considerably more is at stake than collaboration and community. Research
into the effects of AI in education is preliminary but the results are,
so far, grim.
A study conducted by Microsoft suggests that knowledge workers who rely
on generative artificial intelligence engage in less critical thinking.
A field study published by a lead researcher from Georgia Tech reports
that “on average, participants in the ChatGPT group had worse learning
outcomes than those using Google, especially for higher-order critical
learning.” A study of high school math students led by researchers at
the University of Pennsylvania found that students with access to
ChatGPT performed better on tests, but when access was taken away they
performed worse than students who had never had access.
Scholars have groped for what even to call this dire diminishment of
intellectual capacity. “Human enfeeblement” has been proposed, and alike
“cognitive surrender” and even “cognitive extinction.” (You could also
call it, “losing your mind.”) And that’s not even accounting for the
losses of trust and integrity. According to a survey
<https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/4/24/students-ai-usage-by-the-numbers/>
last spring, more than a third of Harvard undergraduates polled used AI
in ways that violated course policies. So far, and, to be sure,
unintentionally, this College’s solution to that problem has been to
relieve faculty of our obligation to teach and students of their
obligation to learn and to make up for the attendant losses of discovery
and humanity by allowing faculty to eat in the dining halls for free.
Deming said two weeks ago that he would produce advisory guidelines on
AI use this year, taking faculty input into account. But nothing about
how the administration has approached this issue suggests that this new
policy will be meaningfully debated or even answerable to evidence.
What is it that we are all here together to do, again?
/Jill Lepore is the David Woods ’41 Professor of American History and
Professor of Law at Harvard./
_______________________________________________
nexa mailing list -- [email protected]
To change settings or unsubscribe please go to:
https://server-nexa.polito.it/postorius/lists/nexa.server-nexa.polito.it/
The general archive of the list is located at:
https://server-nexa.polito.it/hyperkitty/list/[email protected]/
Permalink to this message:
https://server-nexa.polito.it/hyperkitty/list/[email protected]/message/4UZSVUQYY4A4TRNVO3PHME4AQ7QHZXIY/