On 28 Jan 2015, at 12:00 , Keith Schultz <keithjschu...@icloud.com> wrote
>
> We could simply add all kinds of switches and coding to help this process,
> but in the end we end up with an over complicated format that grows into a
> monster!
and
>
> I as an old school type and database person would think it far better, to take
> a more pratical approach.
Most probably I’m not qualified to seriously discuss Bibliography matters in
ConTeXt, but wat Keith has written here appeals to me.
It would probably be OK to try and control all and everything in a Bibliography
with commands and codes if there were only a few standard ways of presenting a
bibliography.
But that is not the case, even if most people seem to use apa-style.
What should one do with an old book, of which there are several “facsimile
editions” and an English translation, and you were required, by the publisher
or the university, to render it in the Bibliography in the following way:
Gasparini, Francesco, L’Armonico pratico al cimbalo (Venice, 1709); repr. (New
York, 1967); repr. (Bologna, 2001); trans. Frank Stillings as The Practical
Harmonist at the Harpsichord (New Haven, CT, 1963)
or, other example:
Buchner, Hans, Das Fundamentbuch (c1525), CH-Bmi, MS F.I.8; ME: in Carl
Paesler, ‘Fundamentbuch von Hans von Constanz, Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte des
Orgelspiels im 16. Jahrhundert’, VMw, 5 (1889), 1-192
?
With a Bibliography to make of about 500 items, for a PhD thesis, of which more
than half were of this kind, I gave up on all sophisticated tools of BibTeX and
exclusively used the format Booklet, with Author, Title, City and PubYear,
generated a .bbl and edited that to give me the correct form.
And, yes, I had to tweak the apa -style a little but that part was easy.
The two examples are in the .bbl-file as follows:
\startpublication[k=Gasparini:2001ublt,t=booklet,
a={{{Gasparini, Francesco}}},y=2001,
n=73,s={Gas}01]
\author[]{}[]{}{{Gasparini, Francesco}}
\pubyear{1963}
\title{{L'armonico pratico al cimbalo {\em (Venice, 1708); repr.~(New York,
1967); repr. (Bologna, 2001); trans.~by Frank Stillings~as} The Practical
Harmonist at the Harpsichord}}
\city{New Haven, CT}
\stoppublication
\startpublication[k=Buchner:1525fblt,t=booklet,
a={{{Buchner, Hans}}},y=,
n=39,s={Buc}]
\author[]{}[]{}{{Buchner, Hans}}
\title{{{Das Fundamentbuch} {\em ({\em c}1525), CH-Bmi, MS F.I.8; ME: in Carl
Paesler, \quote{Fundamentbuch von Hans von Constanz, Ein Beitrag zur
Geschichte des Orgelspiels im 16.~Jahrhundert}}, VMw, {\em 5 (1889), 1-192}}}
\stoppublication
Primitive? Certainly. But it is straightforward, very flexible and it works.
I hope of course that the new Bibliography tool will be very powerful, but I
also hope that it will remain possible, in ConTeXt, to keep doing things in a
simple manner.
Best regards,
Robert Blackstone
___________________________________________________________________________________
If your question is of interest to others as well, please add an entry to the
Wiki!
maillist : ntg-context@ntg.nl / http://www.ntg.nl/mailman/listinfo/ntg-context
webpage : http://www.pragma-ade.nl / http://tex.aanhet.net
archive : http://foundry.supelec.fr/projects/contextrev/
wiki : http://contextgarden.net
___________________________________________________________________________________
