Darren> Right, I'm not a lawyer but I didn't claim I was authoritative it is
Darren> just my opinion!

Cool; thanks for clarifying.


Darren> The problem with seeking a legal opinion is that it will only be
Darren> valid for the law that the lawyer you ask understands and represents,
Darren> it won't be valid worldwide.

True.


Darren> Why are we so concerned about this issue yet we don't seem to be
Darren> concerned about plugging in a random cable ?

Because physical access is required to plug in a cable, whereas it is not
required for wireless.


Darren> If we are concerned about the legal aspect of this then it would
Darren> probably do us good to do what everyone else does rather than being
Darren> different.  If we are different and some how do get the user into
Darren> trouble the user could blame us.

I already conceded that the above was a reasonable point of view.


Darren> IMO it is a very sad day that we have to have a discussion about
Darren> legal issues when considering network connectivity and defaults :-(

Yes, I agree it is sad, but we work for a big company with billions of
dollars in the bank (or wherever it is kept :-) and adding a feature to
a product which could get us sued would be a Bad Thing IMO.

-- John

http://blogs.sun.com/jbeck

Reply via email to