As expected, a sighting of Prothonotary Warbler at Inwood Hill Park on Monday 
late-day, May 11 has received a confirmation for eBird archive listing.  At 
least the 3rd of this species to be noted from N.Y. County, in this month, 
possibly more than that number have occurred by now in May.   Inwood Hill and 
multiple other parks and some greenspaces in northernmost Manhattan are seeing 
as great a May migration as in the rest of Manhattan, thanks to all who find 
birds in all of these many areas. Inwood Hill in particular gives the strongest 
sense of what a forested Manhattan had been like in long-ago times, in portions 
of its relatively old-growth woods. Other parks and a few greenspaces of north 
Manhattan also have venerable trees, and in some neighborhoods also a variety 
of very old buildings, by contrast with most newer structures of this city. 

Manhattan, N.Y. City - into Wednesday, May 13 -

A preface - the similar-looking Gray-cheeked Thrush has been present and any 
number of these have been vocal at times in Central Park and elsewhere in the 
county recently, including on 5-13, and including in the proximity of the 
scarce Bicknells - of course other migrant Catharus-genus thrush species are 
also present in all areas now. Swainsons Thrush is particularly numerous 
throughout, over recent days, and numbers of those also have been vocal at 
times.  With most of these migrant thrushes, songs or even calls given here are 
not as vigorous, sometimes not as full and complete as song or even calls given 
on these species breeding territories. The thrush of brown-backed type which we 
have here as an annual breeder, as well as a passage migrant, is Wood Thrush, 
with of course a markedly different appearance and vocalizations to the other, 
migrant-only Catharus-genus thrush species. 
  The find of a singing Bicknells Thrush is not too unexpected these years, in 
mid to late May in this county, and with a number of gray-cheeked types - most 
readers will know that these were all thought to be one species in the past, 
and Eugene Pintard Bicknell was one of the collectors which was in the long-ago 
days before optics were becoming more the tools of field workers in 
ornithology, who brought a specimen of thrush in to a museum collection, which 
was later recognized as a new species to science. NY state is home to the 
most-southerly breeding range of this threatened, limited-distribution thrush, 
known as Bicknells, and which is closely related to the vastly more-numerous in 
world-distribution Gray-cheeked Thrush, the latter a species that breeds across 
north-boreal Canada into Alaska and even to a bit of Siberian Russia, and which 
winters in entirely separate areas of the nootropics - Bicknells is a Caribbean 
wintering species, most being on Hispaniola, and mainly la Republica Dominicana 
in its main wintering home. One of the Bicknells singing into this Wed. eve was 
in the north end of Central Park, but other locations may be receiving these 
migrants as well.  Please DO NOT play the songs or calls of the 2 gray-cheeked 
and bicknell types repeatedly - it will disturb these birds unnecessarily if at 
all overdone, and keep them from feeding and resting properly.  Trying to make 
audio-video recordings will be far more useful, to learning and in case of 
sharing in bird lists or social media. Patience is key to learning with birds…. 
The Bicknells Thrush was seen and sometimes heard by multiple observers at 
various times of day on Wed, straight into May 13 dusk. In Central Park in 
particular with hundreds, often many-hundreds of birders out every day in all 
weather now in this month of May, one should never presume that others are not 
nearby at any location and at any hours, who are attentively trying to observe 
birds - by both ears and by eyes.  

A Blue Grosbeak showed in the northern part of Riverside Park, at a so-called 
pollinator meadow which is at approximately W. 119-121 Street, n. of a tennis 
court, with dual paths coming in from near the south edge of the tennis courts, 
and not-from a feature in Riverside known as The Drip, as well as just-north of 
the Forever Wild sanctuary in Riverside, which was long known as the Ladies 
Grove, a space protected in various ways for many, many decades from being 
overly-developed or outright having had older trees cut. The areas to the north 
of that grove are now sometimes signed as the sanctuary as well, but were not 
quite a part of the first efforts to conserve the greenspace - although the 
total area of concern over a century ago was large, and included many sections 
of that park. The last meetings of the original conservation group dedicated to 
the northern parts of Riverside Park were in 1938, and the sanctuary as still 
called is still there. In summer 2005, a very old Red Oak —Quercus rubra- fell, 
and had been estimated to have reached well over 300 years of life, some 
estimates to 350 years old. There are still some old, great trees in the area 
and elsewhere in and next to Riverside Park, on the west edges of Manhattan, 
north of W. 72 Street and extending into west Harlem. Riverside Drive is 
all-along the eastern boundary of this venerable park, which incidentally has 
had a very strong influx of migrant and other birds in May this year. Some of 
the birders that go regularly are quite dedicated to this park.  

Yet another Blue Grosbeak sighting comes from not-far-off from the above 
location Morningside Park, at around 122-123rd Sts. on Manhattans - and Harlems 
western side, this park is a longish linear park with some steep slopes, but a 
network of paths and long steep stone steps provide a lot of maneuverability. 
This park, as with many in Manhattan of all sizes and locations, has its 
devoted observers and a lot of species have been noted here, especially in the 
past decade or so with increasing observation-efforts. Timing of the 2 reports 
make it seem a bit unlikely that the Riverside Park BG was the same individual 
as the grosbleu from Morningside, but given the proximity, it may be a 
possibility.

Summer Tanager continues its strong recent showings in Manhattan, the latest 
sighting being at the Chelsea waterside park north of West 23rd St., alongside 
the Hudson River, all west of the W. Side Highway and adjacent greenway trail. 
The Wednesday May 13th sighting at Chelsea-waterside was of a male molting into 
summer-breeding color, and had more than one observer.  There are literally 
hundreds of larger and smaller greenspaces all around mid to lower Manhattan 
which are receiving migrant birds now, in May, with some sites having very 
dedicated observers per particular locations, local patches so to say. These 
include a number of public or partly-public gardens, as well as some 
churchyards open to the public at times, and a wide variety of other 
greenspaces.

The thirty-third warbler species of this spring for Manhattan (and, for all of 
New York County as well) has been noted, at last, the rather-expected by now 
Mourning Warbler, a species already present in multiple breeding areas of the 
northeast U.S. in the past week or longer, and having passed thru other areas 
within N.Y. City as well. Far more of this warbler species should be on the way 
thru in coming days and even to early June. Key, at least with males coming 
thru is that a lot will sing, as most warblers are inclined on passage here, 
and knowing that song, or in lieu of song, knowing calls quite well is helpful 
to locating, or even knowing of the presence of these sometimes-skulking lovers 
of moist tangles - but also these can be and are a bit arboreal at times, from 
lower perches as some will sing from, or forage a bit, while most of their time 
is likely to be within a meter or so of ground or substrate levels.  In recent 
decades, the Mourning Warbler occasionally showed up here even in earliest days 
of May, but is much more-expected by around now - going into the third week of 
May soon.  This species also helps to brings to over 175 species the tally of 
birds just in the month of May in N.Y. County - slightly less than that in 
Manhattan, or seen-from-Manhattan alone, in May, just ahead of the midpoint of 
this month. 

A female E. Bluebird was noted by a group of observers at the n. end of Central 
Park on Wed., while a fairly late date here in this county for the species, it 
is not unprecedented including in mid-May at Central Park. 

Monk Parakeet sightings have continued, with some in northern Manhattan where 
the species has been known to nest in recent years, and also from Central Park 
and other locations of mid-upper Manhattan, where the species has at least been 
occasional for decades. It is a regular, known breeding bird of each of the 
five counties of N.Y. City, but a bit better known in some colonies that 
continue in some of the other parts of the city.  In N.Y. County, any nesters 
have not been successful in forming even modest colonies as far as known - and 
of course, this is a large, green, not all-that-quiet bird. 

We also have a further report of Yellow-breasted Chat, at Fort Tryon Park, 
perhaps a lingerer there where one had been some days ago. It is a species 
which, on migration will sometimes linger in spring, and can disappear for days 
only to return to a general area again after not being noticed over some days. 
In fall to early winters here, this species has -rarely- stayed on for months, 
in locations where the individual had to have been feeding well. More typical 
in spring for this species here are briefer appearances.   A Pine Siskin was 
still being reported at Central Park to Wednesday, and some Purple Finches have 
continued to pass thru Manhattan. A bit late for this county by now, Brown 
Creeper has been reported into this week, and not at all late are some 
sightings of Ruby-crowned Kinglets, even if the latter have peaked on their 
northbound passages and departures from here.  

Many more migrants and breeding birds can be noted in an upcoming report. 
Thanks again to hundreds of very keen and often-energetic observers and 
photographers for great numbers of sightings, alerts in Discord, the app that 
virtually all birders now use for rapid alerting of birds seen as well as for 
other uses, and with very frequent hourly-updated alerts and reports in eBird, 
including the Macaulay Library archiving media in both visual and auditory 
forms. The many word-of-mouth bird reports and hints each day or night are also 
appreciated, the majority coming in-the-field, ie in real-time.

Good ongoing May birds,

Tom Fiore
manhattan

--
NYSbirds-L List Info:
Visit: http://LISTS.cornell.edu for more information
Posting Address: [email protected]
Archives:
The Mail Archive: 
https://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/maillist.html
Sightings: Please submit your observations to eBird at http://www.ebird.org
--

Reply via email to