On Jun 9, 2012, at 1:20 PM, Melinda Shore wrote: > On 6/9/12 12:56 AM, Dick Hardt wrote: >> Mike emailed me the draft and asked if I would publish it. >> I reviewed the draft and I thought it captured consensus. > > Chairs call consensus.
Agreed. I thought it captured the consensus that Hannes was referring to when he asked the edits to be published. > >> I noted that Hannes had asked Eran to publish the edits a week ago >> There have been numerous indications that Eran has lost interest in >> continuing as editor. Eg. his decision to discontinue his work on the >> MAC spec. > > Okay, but why wasn't Eran at least informed, given that he had *not* > announced that he would no longer be editing this document? This sounds > like a bobble by the chairs and a possible overreach by you, and this is > something that should be brought to the attention of the working group > (i.e. the legitimacy of this version of the document is, well, > questionable) but resolved offline by the chairs and editors. A public > apology wouldn't be a terrible thing, either. I was responding to a request to publish the version from Mike and had the impression this was what the chairs wanted. I apologize for all the confusion this has caused. -- Dick _______________________________________________ OAuth mailing list OAuth@ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/oauth
