On Wed, 2011-08-24 at 13:24 -0700, Dennis E. Hamilton wrote: > Simon, > > There is no doubt violent agreement about forums. > > I still would prefer to have some list *also* (after all, [email protected] is > apparently there already) but I can always satisfy my personal workflow > preferences and find lists to support users on. Maybe I can scratch my > support and QA itch on StackOverflow. I would especially want a list for > [email protected] once we recognize how that matters.
A couple of things. Personally I don't have a problem with having both. I do have a problem with how the user mailing list was run in the past. That said - there was, in the case of the English speaking lists actually two active users mailing lists. The main users at oo.o. This was a catch all for every module in the suite, less one, Base. Actually I think each module had a user list but the other module lists where not active. In the case of the Base user list (users at dba.oo.o) the list was active and for myself and some others I saw we would work the forum and the mailing list as a pair. So if you wanted to ask a question about say, how to write a SQL select statement, we would try to get you to the forum and answer the questions there. But if you had a question that required some deep diving then the mailing list was available - the mailing list offered another level of expertise up to and including talking with the actual developers. Some folks might recognize this pattern - way back in the stone age I had a job as manager for a development group producing a couple of apps for the mortgage banking market and as things happen for the better part of one year the added role of managing the customer support group. Now the customer support staff (folks that came from a banking operations background) could field most issues with the software, first level support, but from time to some issue needed second level support (a support engineer, a CS background) or third level, the developers and often Mo Money :-) What I was trying to do was to mimic that same pattern between the forums (1st level) and the mailing list (2nd level) or even 3rd level. 2nd level because there where plenty of working DBAs on the mailing list that where not about to use the forum, but would help with a question on the mailing list and then of course it was also the gateway to the actual developers. (Bugzilla comes into play here also or course..) I can;t make too much of this because it was never spelled out or formal in any way, but it was how I tried to do things for myself and I think it worked quite well, quite often - can we find a way to bring that to a more general solution - not sure, but it could go a long way to making the support better - will developers help with support, I think they will, if people are helping them by taking the true 1st level questions and then passing thru the questions (and here I mean getting the person asking to move to the list if possible) that merit a deeper understanding. anwyay - long email and I'll stop here. //drew
