On Sat, Sep 10, 2011 at 9:49 AM, Dave Fisher <[email protected]> wrote:
> > On Sep 10, 2011, at 9:05 AM, Kay Schenk wrote: > > > On Wed, Sep 7, 2011 at 4:57 PM, Dave Fisher <[email protected]> > wrote: > > > >> Hi Dennis, > >> > >> I am under impression that the license for everything on OOo is PDL, yet > >> almost nothing fulfills the terms. > >> > >> Copyrights are with the Initial Writer. If I can find an Initial Writer > I > >> will mark it - pretty much only in <META> tags although that is whose > OOo > >> back in 2000/2002 created or changed the page or some lists in some > places. > >> > >> As far as copyright where there is no identified Initial Writer should > we: > >> > >> (1) Have no copyright. > >> (2) Put the ASF copyright in place. > >> (3) Put an Oracle copyright on it. > >> (4) Put an OpenOffice.org copyright on it. > >> > >> We can't do (3) we're not Oracle. We should stop doing (2). > >> > >> Unless there is an argument in one direction or another I'll do (1) by > Lazy > >> Consensus. > >> > >> I recommend that as we replace pages with AOOo policies that we create > >> mdtext replacements as fresh files. > >> > >> On Sep 7, 2011, at 4:11 PM, Dennis E. Hamilton wrote: > >> > >>> Dave, > >>> > >>> It would seem that these (few, I believe we're told) can be handled the > >> same as unclear provenance anywhere in the code base and its > dependencies. > >>> > >>> The ideal time to clean these up would be when the site is under the > >> OpenOffice.org domain name but actually hosted on Apache infrastructure. > >> That gives complete ability to make all of the adjustments that are > needed, > >> including the numerous minor ones to connect to the Bugzilla, etc. > >>> > >>> I'm not clear how migration of the wiki is impacted, unless you mean > the > >> proposed movement of material now on static web pages into the wiki? > >> > >> That is my concern. Kay will need to assure that we know which wiki > pages > >> came in as "PDL" as I think they'll need to stay that way. > >> > > > > uh...well I am not sure AT ALL how to determine this esp the pages that > are > > not English. Oh joy -- I'm not a good legal eagle. :( > > I think we will need to count on NL teams to do IP clearance in their own > language and either update, delete or move to the wiki. At least the DE site > is behind in several areas - especially licensing. > Well this would be easiest. I suppose it would be easy enough for the NL project leads to just do an svn (they don't need committer access for anon), and then move to the wiki -- assuming they've got access there. I could certainly do some of this soonish -- next week or so. I'll jsut assume existing structure as we have for "de". > > > > Somehow I have a feeling that when OpenOffice.org spec'd the PDL, we/they > > were just trying to use something convenient that was available in the > > public domain. > > I now believe that most of the site is licensed via OCA and/or Terms of > Use. We'll need to point to sign contributors and mention a some parts are > copyright .... Oracle and a long list of people. We can then get > [email protected] to review. > > > > > Anyway, I'll take a look at the NL sites in the next day or so and see > what > > I can determine. > > Sure, I think that we should proceed with converting everything we can from > the OOo website to our incubator site. Whatever you move to the wiki can be > removed or left as a simple stump that might be able to provide some way to > preserve links into the project. > Well for now, I won't move ANYTHING to wiki, because we have NO actual new OO.o wiki setup. > I'll adjust the wrapping so that we aren't asserting a wrong copyright and > provide a better license link. This will take more work with the Apache CMS. > > When the time comes to standup an Apache hosted openoffice.org we show > what we have, and keep on changing and updating. > > To me the only prerequisites to Apache hosting are: > > (1) align OOo site policies with the AOOo project - clearance from the > podling PPMC and Mentors. > (2) have appropriate license and copyright notices. - clearance from the > apache legal. > (3) have appropriate branding. - clearance from trademarks. > > What do you think? > this sounds fine really. OK, take care -K > > Regards, > Dave > > > > > > > >> > >>> > >>> Exactly where are you finding these PDL license notices? The first one > I > >> found was on the "Open Office.org 3 Installation Guide", a PDF (or ODT) > >> reachable from <http://download.openoffice.org/common/instructions.html > >. > >> If we *don't touch it* can't it be retained until a > permissively-licenses > >> alternative is needed? I don't see a reason to be concerned that the > >> authors/contributors did not properly execute the instructions of the > >> license they have offered. > >> > >> That's not the concern, the concern is if StarOffice, Sun, and/or Oracle > >> lost the paperwork. I suppose should we be presented with a copy of the > PDL > >> from an Initial Writer then we fix the issue. > >> > >> Regards, > >> Dave > >> > >>> > >>> - Dennis > >>> > >>> RELAXED RETAIN, SUPPLEMENT, AND REPLACE SCENARIO > >>> > >>> If the notices are always in standalone documents such as the > >> Installation Guide, I don't see any problem making them available the > same > >> way they are now. They should simply be left intact. They can be > replaced > >> by non-derivative replacements later, when there are Apache OOo releases > >> that require different information. I don't see why we have to hurry. > >> Instructions for existing releases remain valuable to keep around. I > >> suggest preserving them right where they are, where people expect to > find > >> them. > >>> > >>> When there are releases from Apache OOo, supplementary documents could > be > >> offered. That would be another way to provide specific information > >> applicable to later releases. I see considerable time before these > >> PDL-licensed documents need to be supplanted. They might be retained for > a > >> very long time. > >>> > >>> > >>> - Dennis > >>> > >>> -----Original Message----- > >>> From: Dave Fisher [mailto:[email protected]] > >>> Sent: Wednesday, September 07, 2011 14:33 > >>> To: [email protected] > >>> Subject: Re: Concerns about all PDL website material > >>> > >>> > >>> On Sep 7, 2011, at 2:16 PM, Rob Weir wrote: > >>> > >>>> On Wed, Sep 7, 2011 at 4:44 PM, Dave Fisher <[email protected]> > >> wrote: > >>>>> I am stuck on a licensing issue with the OpenOffice.org website and I > >> begin to doubt if can do much with it other than rehost and correct > obvious > >> changes in policy. > >>>>> > >>>>> Please look at http://www.openoffice.org/licenses/PDL.html > >>>>> > >>>>> (Whether the PDL is category A for Apache is a follow up, but there > is > >> no point without resolving the following.) > >>>>> > >>>>> Specifically look at: > >>>>> > >>>>>> Required Notices. > >>>>>> You must duplicate the notice in the Appendix in each file of the > >> Documentation. If it is not possible to put such notice in a particular > >> Documentation file due to its structure, then You must include such > notice > >> in a location (such as a relevant directory) where a reader would be > likely > >> to look for such a notice, for example, via a hyperlink in each file of > the > >> Documentation that takes the reader to a page that describes the origin > and > >> ownership of the Documentation. If You created one or more > Modification(s) > >> You may add your name as a Contributor to the notice described in the > >> Appendix. > >>>>>> You must also duplicate this License in any Documentation file (or > >> with a hyperlink in each file of the Documentation) where You describe > >> recipients' rights or ownership rights. > >>>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>> and > >>>>> > >>>>>> Appendix > >>>>>> Public Documentation License Notice > >>>>>> The contents of this Documentation are subject to the Public > >> Documentation License Version 1.0 (the "License"); you may only use this > >> Documentation if you comply with the terms of this License. A copy of > the > >> License is available at __________________[Insert hyperlink]. > >>>>>> The Original Documentation is _________________. The Initial Writer > of > >> the Original Documentation is ___________ Copyright (C)_________[Insert > >> year(s)]. All Rights Reserved. (Initial Writer > >> contact(s):________________[Insert hyperlink/alias]). > >>>>>> Contributor(s): ______________________________________. > >>>>>> Portions created by ______ are Copyright (C)_________[Insert > year(s)]. > >> All Rights Reserved. (Contributor contact(s):________________[Insert > >> hyperlink/alias]). > >>>>>> NOTE: The text of this Appendix may differ slightly from the text of > >> the notices in the files of the Original Documentation. You should use > the > >> text of this Appendixrather than the text found in the Original > >> Documentation for Your Modifications. > >>>>> > >>>> > >>>> Does it ever actually require that someone fill in the blanks in the > >>>> Appendix? I see that it requires one to duplicate the notice in the > >>>> appendix. And it permits (but does not require) initial writers and > >>>> contributors to add their names to the Appendix. > >>> > >>> If no one seems to ever provide this information then what can we > assume? > >> If there is no Initial Writer then who holds the copyright? Where's the > >> paperwork? Where does that leave us? Square one on the website and > anything > >> derived from PDL? > >>> > >>> Regards, > >>> Dave > >>> > >>>> > >>>>> I can find no answer to the question about who are the initial > writers > >> and further contributors are for all most all web pages. There are some > that > >> have meta tags, but that is not following the terms. > >>>>> > >>>>> Can anyone provide help here? Do most pages have an "INitial Writer" > >> and "Contributor" of Oracle Corporation? > >>>>> > >>>>> Would we need to see if the archives from prior to the kenai > migration > >> have enough history to determine "Initial Writers" and "Contributors"? > >>>>> > >>>>> Where are these appendices? > >>>>> > >>>>> I don't see any point in working on the OOo website or transfers to > >> MWiki or CWiki without clarification. > >>>>> > >>>>> Regards, > >>>>> Dave > >>> > >> > >> > > > > > > -- > > > --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- > > MzK > > > > "There's something about the sound of a train > > that's very romantic and nostalgic and hopeful." > > -- Paul Simon > > -- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- MzK "There's something about the sound of a train that's very romantic and nostalgic and hopeful." -- Paul Simon
