On Tue, Oct 25, 2011 at 6:41 AM, Rob Weir <[email protected]> wrote: > On Tue, Oct 25, 2011 at 6:28 AM, Simon Phipps <[email protected]> wrote: >> On Mon, Oct 24, 2011 at 8:20 PM, Pedro Giffuni <[email protected]> wrote: >> >>> >>> If libreoffice encourages, but not requires, AL2 >>> for stuff in the core package, that would be a huge >>> advance to get a bit nearer both camps. >>> >> >> Given licenses are the expression of the ethos of a community, it's > > LO had no choice but to take LGPL. So more necessity/inertia than > ethos. And -- according to Michael -- when it thought that MPL might > be more acceptable TDF was quick to add MPL for new code > contributions. This shows an ethos of flexibility.
And look how well it has served us. Despite that very large concession, IBM still snubbed it and 9 month later started a new fork. You give a hand, it want the whole body... > This is a good thing. Only in others right ? Do as I say not as I do... [ snip trolling ] > >> disingenuous and divisive to assume any community will drop its governance >> approach like this, Pedro. It translates as "the path to collaboration is >> your surrender; we can negotiate once you've done that". You make it sound > > This is obviously a touchy subject for you, Simon. But please read > what Pedro wrote. He said: > > "If libreoffice encourages, but not requires, AL2 for stuff in the > core package, that would be a huge advance to get a bit nearer both > camps." > > This is not asking for LO members to surrender or fall on their > swords. As a TDF member, I'm telling you: Yes it is _exactly_ what it sound like. > It is suggesting that information be made available to LO > developers who might wish to voluntarily make their code available > under ALv2 as well as the existing LGPL/MPL. Please correct me if > I'm wrong, but I had the impression that nothing at TDF/LO that would > prevent someone from doing this? It is one thing to not 'prevent' someone from abandoning free-software principles (as if anyone had such power anyway) It is quite another to have "libreoffice [more exactly TDF] ask its members" or contributors to do so Norbert
