Am 10/28/2011 03:38 AM, schrieb Gavin McDonald:


-----Original Message-----
From: Marcus (OOo) [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Friday, 28 October 2011 9:13 AM
To: [email protected]
Cc: Peter Pöml
Subject: Re: Shutdown of the "download.services.openoffice.org" host and
its Mirrorbrain instance

Am 10/27/2011 11:36 AM, schrieb Gavin McDonald:


-----Original Message-----
From: Ross Gardler [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Thursday, 27 October 2011 10:48 AM
To: [email protected]
Cc: Peter Pöml
Subject: Re: Shutdown of the "download.services.openoffice.org" host
and its Mirrorbrain instance

Sent from my mobile device, please forgive errors and brevity.
On Oct 27, 2011 1:22 AM, "Marcus (OOo)"<[email protected]>
wrote:

Am 10/27/2011 02:03 AM, schrieb Ross Gardler:

Sent from my mobile device, please forgive errors and brevity.
On Oct 27, 2011 12:37 AM, "Marcus (OOo)"<[email protected]>
wrote:

Am 10/26/2011 11:57 PM, schrieb Peter Pöml:

....

Setting up MirrorBrain would be one way, but it would require
replication additional configuration (for instance, download
statistics)
that we have built on the current download server
(download.services.openoffice.org).

Another way would be to simply have a virtual machine, where we
move
the
current server to. That would cause the least effort, I guess.

+1 this should be really our goal for now ...

...

Starting from scratch would mean to lose a lot of the previos
work
-- and I really mean lots, which I dare to judge because I spent
a lot of time with download.services.openoffice.org.

On the other hand, having MirrorBrain at the core of the ASF's
mirror system could be interesting for other projects, too. I
know closer.cgi but I'm sure that MirrorBrain could serve the ASF
well.
(Well possible as an addition, rather than a replacement, for a
soft transition.) That might outweigh the pain of creating OOo's
download service from scratch in a different environment.

... and this the long term goal.

The ASF can really benefit from this way of downloading software.

Currently you have to choose a mirror, then change to the directory
structure where the respective binary is located and finally
download it.

This is not correct. I have no idea if the ASF can benefit from
MirrorBrain
or not, but if your justification for such a statement is based on
the above
erroneous analysis of the current mirror system then I have my
concerns.
I

OK, thats what I've done to come to my point:
- browse to "http://www.apache.org/";
- click on "Download" top right
- choose a mirror
- change to the dir structure to your file
- now download

Is there an easier way to get software?

E.g. http://httpd.apache.org/download.cgi#apache22

It auto selects the nearest mirror and provides appropriate download
links
- a
single click. Want it pretty with big blue buttons? It's just HTML

This was discussed early in the AOOo podlings existence.see archives
for.more.

I would like us to move on from this Topic, I have said before and I
will say it again, ASF Infra will NOT support mirrorbrain.

We have one mirror system and it deals with 200 or so projects.
OpenOffice project will use the current ASF supported mirror system. End
of story.

If you see this like black and white then I can do this, too:

If we don't get the support that AOO needs then we can outsource the
download easily. EOD

(yes, this wasn't meant seriously)

It's sad that you brush it simply aside without to see the chance to at
least try
to improve things.

Excuse me? I am doing quite a lot already thank you.
You do not our infrastructure or how it works, I do.

And we are all very thankful for this. This wasn't meant as offense. Sorry if you have understood it this way.

Why OOo is special:

- OOo 3.3 consists of ~1.000 files with ~70 GB

Correct.

- in the peak with 300,000 downloads per day

That’s fine. The mirrors will handle that.

OK, forget the other numbers as of course only this is important for the topic.

Even when we won't get back the download numbers in the middle run due
to the long silence of the last months and reduce the number by lets say
50%
we would be still by far the largest ASF project.

Doesn’t give you the right to try and bully me or the rest of the infra team
into
giving you want you want. In fact, it will have the opposite effect.

Stop. I haven't bully you and never the entire infra team. Again, sorry if you have understood it this way.

But you are right ...

That said, let us get these other migrations done and we can see
how/if the previous releases can be integrated.

... currently we have indeed other more important road works on the plan.


And we are working on them.

The downloads will be sorted don’t worry, but if I can help it, it will be
using the same
system as all the other projects. If I am wrong about that, I will fess up
if it happens.

Marcus

Reply via email to