On 2011-11-20 3:19 AM, eric b wrote:
Hi,


Le 20 nov. 11 à 01:30, Kay Schenk a écrit :

OK, I truly hate to make a comment like this, but...

eric b, any chance you could take your issues with Louis somewhere other
than this list?

Kay has a point, and in a more established Apache project this kind of discussion would *not* be appreciated. However I understand that there's a lot of history in the previous OpenOffice.org project, especially with a lot of strong-willed individuals, so I'll contribute to this thread.

Everything I reported are facts, that you can verify in the archives.
I'm simply describing a system who caused a disaster in OpenOffice.org.
Louis was just one ot "the band".

If what people reported me is true, this "Monarchy" is still alive (I've
heard of "discussions with old Community Council") , and probably, there
is one plan behind the wood.

Do you have specific references to such behavior happening within an Apache project?

If you do not, well, then I can only say with my 9 years of experience being an Apache Member that Monarchies are *not* tolerated at Apache, and if the relevant (P)PMC can't ensure that the community acts in an open and meritocratic way, that either the Incubator PMC or the board will step in to ensure that it does (or, will terminate the podling/project).

I can also say with my AOO Mentor hat that from my perspective, the Community Council of the previous OpenOffice.org project is gone, ceased, no longer exists as an officially recognized organization. A lot of past organizational structures that were related to the Sun or Oracle led project in the past are gone; it's just that Oracle never bothered to officially announce the end of them (as best I can see). It's obvious that a number of people who used to have titles or roles in those organizations are hoping to get them back or otherwise continue to use them, but they have no meaning within the governance of this Apache podling.

I also think it's pretty clear from the discussions here by the most active PPMC members (in terms of actual commits, not mailing list traffic) that this PPMC explicitly does not want to re-form any of the structures from the previous OpenOffice.org project.

As volunteer, not being paid, and working a lot on the code in my spare
time, I'd like to concentrate me on something ethical and true, to avoid
this occur again, and see the MERIT and TRUE CONTRIBUTIONS (not only
code) being the motor, but not politics, nor mind manipulators.


If I have some doubts, or if ever the old crappy system is back, I
promise to immediately stop to contribute to Apache OpenOffice.org,
without regret.

Yes, you've said this before (in terms of leaving the project if you couldn't know Hagar's true identity), which I have to say from my perspective doesn't help your argument any (at least not in the typical Apache Way mindset).

- Shane



This is, I believe, the second personal rant I've seen like this, and
I, for one, don't really feel it's appropriate for the venue.


Well, if you read carefully :
http://wiki.services.openoffice.org/wiki/Community_Council_Log_20091217

... you'll read that I "alienated developers" : [15:27:41] louis_to and
the fact that the lead seems to alienate a lot of develoopers,
arccording to reports


Please be curious : notice the name of the people present, and think
what's happening with them today.

My reaction is not a rant, but rather some "please, Apache people, open
your eyes".



Regards,
Eric


Reply via email to