On 14/12/2011 Rob Weir wrote:
On Tue, Dec 13, 2011 at 7:38 PM, Andrea Pescetti
But can someone explain why the icons
were changed in the first place?  Surely, someone had an argument for
this at the time?

In the wiki page Pedro linked there's a further link to the official explanation page, now dead but still on archive.org at
http://web.archive.org/web/20091004033006/http://blogs.sun.com/GullFOSS/entry/unified_odf_icons

Comments are worth reading too, but the ideas were: making unified ODF icons as Herbert wrote (good, but hasn't happened) and get rid of the curve in the old icons (you can still find them at http://img8.imageshack.us/img8/3623/ooomedie.png ) which supposedly was an S and meant Sun; honestly, users couldn't care less about the S.

You mention flamewars.  That suggests there were two points of view.
It is hard to have a flamewar where eveyone agrees. ;-)

It was mostly Oracle vs rest-of-the-world (even though probably a large percentage of users didn't care much). Especially irritating to critics was seeing that the redesign effort http://wiki.services.openoffice.org/wiki/ODF_icons_i-team (this is the redesign effort started AFTER complaints were made, so the redesign of the new icons) started with the premise that colors wouldn't come back and tried variants on the monochrome design, thus persisting in a widely criticized attitude. It was, in a way, a clear fracture between Oracle and the community, even if one sees it from a non-political point of view.

Regards,
  Andrea.

Reply via email to