Michael,

I think the language selections are for writing aids, not UI and Help 
internationalization.  You might want several even though your UI is English, 
for example.  

If you look at the OOo-dev 3.4 beta release, you'll see that there is only a 
full release (with Java JRE too, I suppose, on Windows) for English.  This will 
be an English UI plus writing aids for a few flavors each of en, fr, and one 
for es.  All other languages, including any UI internationalization, are via 
langpacks, one per listed language.  The langpack adds a UI language and 
embedded help internationalizations, as available, and whatever writing aids 
there are for that language, also as available.

For the supplemental Italian langpack install that I did as an experiment, when 
I select the UI language to be Italian, the embedded help switches to Italian 
also.

The enumeration is here: <http://download.openoffice.org/all_beta.html>.

I notice that LibreOffice 3.4 install for Windows-en includes the writing aids 
for just over 30 native languages.  (Sometimes variants are in separate sets, 
sometimes multiple variants are in the same aid folder.)  The embedded help is 
a separate helppack download and install.  It's true that the installed 
extensions take almost 200MB when extracted into the file system, including 
non-writing-aid extensions that are included in the install.  

This does not answer your question about where the bar is on UI 
internationalization, but it should make clear what a langpack can provide.  

One factor in packaging has to do with the size of full installs on Windows and 
a desire to minimize the number of them.  I have no insight into that.  There 
are many variables that factor into it.  It is undoubtedly not a 
one-size-fits-all, but having the volunteers to create and verify many 
variations is an additional factor.  It might be a reasonable downstream 
business though.

 - Dennis

-----Original Message-----
From: Michael Bauer [mailto:[email protected]] 
Sent: Saturday, December 17, 2011 04:14
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: How many languages will Apache OpenOffice support?

[ ... ]

Sorry if the questions is naive but can you define a langpack language? 
I never took part at that level with OOO. Are those languages without 
localized Help? Just a question (and i have no answer) but more and more 
software I get doesn't use in-product Help but refers you to a Wiki etc. 
Might it not make sense to consider making in-product Help optional and 
referring to a Help website for the most part?

Secondly, a more sensible, slimline install would certainly sound sense 
to me. It's been a while since I did the install but if I recall 
correctly, you actually download the English install with all the 
langpacks and then have to manually pick your language. Which is 
bonkers. If I've selected Tamil as my language of choice, then I don't 
need my bandwidth cluttered up with the other 50 languages. I should 
*only* get Tamil, with no further messing about. The full pack only 
makes sense if you're installing more than one language at the same time.

That to me would be the two most obvious ways of saving space and 
bandwidth, so

> - Move help and other things into a separate download file. - Reduce 
> the doubled data and libraries in the package files. - Improve the 
> installer to download langpacks that the user wants. - etc.

Amen to all of these!

Michael

Reply via email to