On 1/4/12 9:03 AM, eric b wrote:
Hi Rob,
Le 4 janv. 12 à 02:24, Rob Weir a écrit :
Note that this does not become your product's name. It is a logo, like
"Intel Inside", that can be used by 3rd party products that include or
are based on an Apache product.
This point is ESSENTIAL, and imho, only official Apache OpenOffice.org
websites should use the logo.
Though, if 3rd party product want to mention they are based on Apache
product, then they can write it, and why not, add the apache logo. But
not the OpenOffice.org one.
So it allows you to grow your own brand while accurately expressing
your use of the Apache code. We'd need to think how this could work
with products based on legacy OOo releases, pre Apache.
This is a bad track. Indeed, people are already completly confused.
At one recent event, I discussed with some around 20 average french
people (randomly, average users, not following OpenOffice.org story),
and the result is :
- Oracle is the current OpenOffice.org owner
- OpenOffice.org is no longer free and Oracle killed it
- LibreOffie is the new name of OpenOffice.org
- Apache OpenOffice is yet another fork, nobody knows and nobody cares.
It took me a long time to explain them what happened in meantime.
i made similar experience but not exactly the same.
- many people thought OpenOffice.org was killed by Oracle
- many see LibreOffice as fork but the one that currently is alive and
that does strong promotion and is well established as default on the
Linux distros (where it is simply the replacement of a former fork)
- Apache OpenOffice is not well known and many people don't know the
relation between OpenOffice.org and Apache. -> it's our job to change
this ;-)
I invite everybody to repeat the test, and share what they obtain.
But I think something similar could be discussed.
If we wanted, we could also include a link on the main download page,
pointing too White Label Office, but we'd need to be fair and offer
the same kind of link to anyone else who was based on OOo, and who was
respecting the trademarks, e.g., LibreOffice, Symphony, etc.
IMHO, the right decision is to NOT add external links at all : easy to
manage, and always fair for all.
To justify this point of view, I got one famous example in mind : one
NeoOffice link was added (Simon Phipps around already ...) on the main
OpenOffice.org porting project web page. It was a disaster for
OpenOffice.org because people were confused, and thought NeoOffice was
the "official" Mac OS X port. This way, NeoOffice derivated a long time
the porting project forces, including donations who were derivated too.
The case is exactly the same with LibreOffice today, and I strongly
suggest to retain the lesson of the past, and to not redo the same mistake.
Defend the name, and control the logo usage, is ESSENTIAL. Just
wondering how long it will take to the Apache people, to understand that
it was the worse decision ever to rename** OpenOffice.org into Apache
OpenOffice (instead of Apache OpenOffice.org, far better).
i am not sure and I hope we can transport the message of the new name.
When i voted for the change i thought I would have voted for the change
of the project name only (my mistake) and not the product name. We will
see, a good promotion and communication work in the public is necessary
here...
But we will keep www.openoffice.org as the main entry portal page to our
project.
We still have to answer many questions related the change of the product
name
- name of the installation directory and user directory
- name of the tooltip (e.g. mouse over the icon in the dock on a MacOS
system)
- menu entries or application name in the different systems
- registry entries on a windows system
- ...
For most of these question i would recommend to keep OpenOffice.org at
least for AOO 3.4.
Juergen