Why hasn't there been a LEGAL jira issue filed about this at this point? As I said it's a gray area that I'm certain the IPMC has no existing governing policy on, and I'm also certain that your mentors will disagree in the opinions they are providing to you.
As a practical matter, I doubt the legal team will express anything other than a preference, deferring the policy question to the IPMC. So if you are dissatisfied with their preference, the nexthoop to jump thru is general@incubator, where Ross' already-provided opinion is what I'd bet the majority will agree with. Good luck. >________________________________ > From: Pedro Giffuni <[email protected]> >To: [email protected]; Joe Schaefer <[email protected]> >Sent: Friday, January 13, 2012 9:52 AM >Subject: Re: Category-B tarballs in SVN (was Re: External libraries) > >Hello; > >--- Ven 13/1/12, Joe Schaefer <[email protected]> ha scritto: > >> It's certainly an edge case, and I'm not completely convinced >> that I agree with you about it Ross. The ASF's position >> on svn distributions is that you can put anything in there >> that you like, provided we have the legal authority to >> redistribute it. There are no other conditions to my knowledge, >> which is why we've had GPL code amongst other code in there. >> > >I for one signed an iCLA and considering section 7, I >wouldn't go ahead and commit copyleft content to SVN >without discussing it carefully. > >Rob has gone unilaterally about declaring what he >thinks as a known truth and assuming because he wrote >it on a wiki and no one has complained then it is the >one true way (TM). In his defense I have to say he did >ask the right questions but he didn't get concrete answers. > >I think Andrea Pescetti has given us a lesson on how things >are done. Who knows, I think if Rob does a well thought >proposal to legal@ and we all give our feedback concerning >the shortcomings or relative virtues of this approach we may >get to something. > >Pedro. > > >
