On Tue, May 29, 2012 at 2:29 PM, Pedro Giffuni <[email protected]> wrote: > Hi Drew; > > --- Mar 29/5/12, drew <[email protected]> ha scritto: > > <snip> > >> > >> >> >>> >> Yes the situation was specifically postponed as a graduation >>> >> issue, I am not going through that discussion again. >>> >> >>> >> I made a concrete proposal with two alternatives: >>> >> >>> >> - They are moved to a friendly ftp/http site. >>> >> - I step down from the PPMC to avoid the community >>> >> the pain of a -1 vote. >>> > > ... >> >> Could be - it was just the way Pedro phrased his comment I >> thought perhaps his thinking was being influenced by the >> earlier remarks. >> > > The idea that we have remaining issues with Category-B > tarballs in the tree has been around since before the > release, and one of our mentors (Ross I recall) did > acknowledge my point of view. >
Again, I don't see an issue here. But if you feel strongly about this you are welcome to copy the ext_sources over to Apache Extras and do a trivial update of the build script. Whatever makes you happy. But I'd find it odd if any substantial issue of policy could really be addressed by simply changing a URL. To me that sounds like worshiping some formalism rather than actually understanding the policy and its intentions. > I did offer to step down then but I don't mean to make > a big issue out of this. If I step down it will be > communicated in the private list exclusively. I would > still be a committer and nothing would really change > for me. > > What I feel is disappointing is the lack of > acknowledgement that there *is* an issue. Category-B > software can be included in releases in binary form > but it should be otherwise actively discouraged, and in > general unsupported: it should not be included in the > buildbots and using it should be, in general terms, a > PITA. > > IMHO this project benefited greatly from the Category-X > replacement and in general I would like the project to > head in a direction that will lead to greater license > and code simplification but the current situation where > we work-around the policy issues instead of solving them > is (again IMO) unacceptable. > > Pedro.
