On 7/10/12 1:37 AM, Rob Weir wrote: > On Mon, Jul 9, 2012 at 7:05 PM, Dave Fisher <[email protected]> wrote: >> >> On Jul 9, 2012, at 3:39 PM, Rob Weir wrote: >> >>> This looks interesting/useful: https://comments.apache.org/ >>> >>> Would this make sense for our core files under /ooo-site ? >> >> This is very cool. >> >> I think it can be used effectively on the API site, why, downloads, and many >> other parts of ooo-site. >> >> I would not add this to any NL sites without proper moderators. >> > > I would not put it on the main home page or the download page, or > similar pages where the extreme volume would almost certainly lead to > large numbers of out-of-place support questions being posted. On a > page with 5 million+ monthly hits, all it takes is 0.1% user confusion > for us to get flooded. > > But it would probably work for API pages, or building guide, pages > that are technical instructions. Release notes or install > instructions would be other examples, albeit with much greater > traffic. > >> I would start with one or two pages to get the formula correct. Once found >> turning the page on will become part of the site template and controlled >> from the ssi.mdtext in the templates dir. >> > > It would be good to know also how we manage this as pages are revised > and when we use this versus anonymous CMS. For example, if a user > puts a comment that says, "Step X should really say 'foo'", then if we > later modify that page, then we have the extra step of going back to > delete the comment, I assume. > > > In any case, might make sense to pilot this in a small, focused way to > see how users will use it. > > But certainly exciting possibilities!
indeed and we had thought about such a feature in the past for our API reference. See for exmaple3 the PHP reference here http://www.php.net/manual/en/language.basic-syntax.php The question is how we can integrate the feedback in a proper way... But it is indeed very interesting. Juergen > > > -Rob > >> Regards, >> Dave >> >>> >>> -Rob >>
