On 8/27/2012 9:32 PM, Fernando Cassia wrote:
On Mon, Aug 27, 2012 at 12:25 PM, Issac Goldstand <[email protected]>wrote:

Maybe I'm missing something, but how is trying to police 3rd party
(Google) ads on a 3rd party (SF) distribution link a real concern of
this PPMC?

Adverts (and the downloads to go along with this) have been popular on
massive download portals for years, and will be for years to come.

You have to admit, however, that including large green "download" buttons
in the middle of an advert banner, and knowing that such ad is displayed
while the end user is waiting for the Sourceforge.net download to begin, is
misleading to say the least...

I think a simple SF.net policy of asking advertisers not to include such
imagery on its banners would suffice to eliminate all criticism and user
confusion....

FC

You're missing the point. 1) It's not an SF.net policy; it's a Google policy, since they are serving ads to SF.net 2) SF.net and Google are earning too much income from these banners to remove them - especially because 3) the confusion is exactly the point; it's got extremely high click rate and it's what makes that commercial ecosystem tick. Besides, 4) Google policy won't allow a direct download link from a click - in all of these scenarios there's another landing page with a download button (AFAIK, auto-download is not allowed), and that download page can't look like SF.net

So yes, users will be confused, download the wrong thing - heck a clever advertiser would bundle some of this software with a real openoffice install, too (appropriately branded or re-branded to avoid TM infringement) - but this isn't, and shouldn't, be the concern of the PPMC.


  Issac

Reply via email to