OK, now THIS is a REALLY weird one...don't know if anyone's ever seen this.
I'm running some simple test code against one of our new system
configurations, that enumerates the entities, enumerates the sensors in
each entity, and probes the current values (of all threshold sensors,
anyway, as those are the ones I'm interested in). However, I get
*different* results for the sensors whether I access the BMC via the LAN
interface, or locally with the SMI interface!
The full listing is below, but here's the summary of the differences:
(1) Two fan names are different:
LAN: "Fan7/CPU1" => SMI: "Fan7"
LAN: "Fan8/CPU2" => SMI: "Fan8"
(2) The LAN results show an extra sensor: "-12V". (With what may be a
bogus value of -20.60.)
Also, as you can see, some of the temperature sensors are giving back
obviously broken values (-102.0 degrees Celsius? I don' theenk so,
Lucy!). But that's a different issue.
Now, aren't I supposed to get the same values back, no matter which
interface I use to access the BMC?
Eric
Sensor enumeration and values when connecting under LAN:
=========================================================
-- Saw entity [Unknown] node23-ipmi(46.1) ()
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(46.1).0
Type: sensor specific
Measures: watchdog_2
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(46.1).0
Type: sensor specific
Measures: system_event
**** Finished enumerating sensors on entity [Unknown] node23-ipmi(46.1)
-- Saw entity [Unknown] node23-ipmi(0.0) ()
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(0.0).0
Type: sensor specific
Measures: platform_security
**** Finished enumerating sensors on entity [Unknown] node23-ipmi(0.0)
-- Saw entity [Unknown] node23-ipmi(3.0) (Present)
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(3.0).Thermal Trip0
Type: discrete_state
Measures: module_board
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(3.0).CPU Overheat
Type: discrete_state
Measures: module_board
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(3.0).CPU0 Internal E
Type: discrete_state
Measures: module_board
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(3.0).Fan8/CPU2
Type: threshold
Measures: fan
Expressed in: RPM
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(3.0).Fan7/CPU1
Type: threshold
Measures: fan
Expressed in: RPM
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(3.0).CPU1 Vcore
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(3.0).CPU Temp 2
Type: threshold
Measures: temperature
Expressed in: C
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(3.0).CPU Temp 1
Type: threshold
Measures: temperature
Expressed in: C
**** Finished enumerating sensors on entity [Unknown] node23-ipmi(3.0)
-- Saw entity [Unknown] node23-ipmi(3.1) (Present)
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(3.1).Thermal Trip1
Type: discrete_state
Measures: module_board
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(3.1).CPU1 Internal E
Type: discrete_state
Measures: module_board
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(3.1).CPU2 Vcore
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(3.1).CPU Temp 4
Type: threshold
Measures: temperature
Expressed in: C
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(3.1).CPU Temp 3
Type: threshold
Measures: temperature
Expressed in: C
**** Finished enumerating sensors on entity [Unknown] node23-ipmi(3.1)
-- Saw entity [Unknown] node23-ipmi(7.0) (Present)
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(7.0).Fan6
Type: threshold
Measures: fan
Expressed in: RPM
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(7.0).Fan5
Type: threshold
Measures: fan
Expressed in: RPM
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(7.0).Fan4
Type: threshold
Measures: fan
Expressed in: RPM
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(7.0).Fan3
Type: threshold
Measures: fan
Expressed in: RPM
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(7.0).Fan2
Type: threshold
Measures: fan
Expressed in: RPM
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(7.0).Fan1
Type: threshold
Measures: fan
Expressed in: RPM
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(7.0).VBAT
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(7.0).5VSB
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(7.0).1.5V
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(7.0).-12V
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(7.0).12V
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(7.0).5V
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(7.0).3.3V
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(7.0).Sys Temp
Type: threshold
Measures: temperature
Expressed in: C
**** Finished enumerating sensors on entity [Unknown] node23-ipmi(7.0)
-- Saw entity [Unknown] node23-ipmi(23.1) (Present)
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(23.1).Intrusion
Type: sensor specific
Measures: physical_security
**** Finished enumerating sensors on entity [Unknown] node23-ipmi(23.1)
-- Saw entity [Unknown] node23-ipmi(10.0) (Present)
---- Saw sensor: node23-ipmi(10.0).Power Supply
Type: discrete_state
Measures: power_supply
**** Finished enumerating sensors on entity [Unknown] node23-ipmi(10.0)
** Finished enumerating entities on domain node23-ipmi
Sensor node23-ipmi(3.0).Fan8/CPU2 value: 0 [Raw: 0]
Sensor node23-ipmi(3.0).Fan7/CPU1 value: 0 [Raw: 0]
Sensor node23-ipmi(3.0).CPU1 Vcore value: 1.82 [Raw: 227]
Sensor node23-ipmi(3.0).CPU Temp 2 value: 24.0 [Raw: 24]
Sensor node23-ipmi(3.0).CPU Temp 1 value: 27.0 [Raw: 27]
Sensor node23-ipmi(3.1).CPU2 Vcore value: 0.90 [Raw: 113]
Sensor node23-ipmi(3.1).CPU Temp 4 value: -102.0 [Raw: 154]
Sensor node23-ipmi(3.1).CPU Temp 3 value: 46.0 [Raw: 46]
Sensor node23-ipmi(7.0).Fan6 value: 9600 [Raw: 96]
Sensor node23-ipmi(7.0).Fan5 value: 9400 [Raw: 94]
Sensor node23-ipmi(7.0).Fan4 value: 0 [Raw: 0]
Sensor node23-ipmi(7.0).Fan3 value: 9500 [Raw: 95]
Sensor node23-ipmi(7.0).Fan2 value: 9600 [Raw: 96]
Sensor node23-ipmi(7.0).Fan1 value: 19200 [Raw: 192]
Sensor node23-ipmi(7.0).VBAT value: 3.22 [Raw: 201]
Sensor node23-ipmi(7.0).5VSB value: 2.93 [Raw: 122]
Sensor node23-ipmi(7.0).1.5V value: 3.15 [Raw: 197]
Sensor node23-ipmi(7.0).-12V value: -20.60 [Raw: 206]
Sensor node23-ipmi(7.0).12V value: 19.97 [Raw: 208]
Sensor node23-ipmi(7.0).5V value: 3.34 [Raw: 139]
Sensor node23-ipmi(7.0).3.3V value: 1.42 [Raw: 89]
Sensor node23-ipmi(7.0).Sys Temp value: -102.0 [Raw: 154]
Sensor enumeration and values when connecting under SMI:
=========================================================
-- Saw entity [Unknown] node23(46.1) ()
---- Saw sensor: node23(46.1).0
Type: sensor specific
Measures: watchdog_2
---- Saw sensor: node23(46.1).0
Type: sensor specific
Measures: system_event
**** Finished enumerating sensors on entity [Unknown] node23(46.1)
-- Saw entity [Unknown] node23(0.0) ()
---- Saw sensor: node23(0.0).0
Type: sensor specific
Measures: platform_security
**** Finished enumerating sensors on entity [Unknown] node23(0.0)
-- Saw entity [Unknown] node23(3.0) (Present)
---- Saw sensor: node23(3.0).Thermal Trip0
Type: discrete_state
Measures: module_board
---- Saw sensor: node23(3.0).CPU Overheat
Type: discrete_state
Measures: module_board
---- Saw sensor: node23(3.0).CPU0 Internal E
Type: discrete_state
Measures: module_board
---- Saw sensor: node23(3.0).CPU1 Vcore
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23(3.0).CPU Temp 2
Type: threshold
Measures: temperature
Expressed in: C
---- Saw sensor: node23(3.0).CPU Temp 1
Type: threshold
Measures: temperature
Expressed in: C
**** Finished enumerating sensors on entity [Unknown] node23(3.0)
-- Saw entity [Unknown] node23(3.1) (Present)
---- Saw sensor: node23(3.1).Thermal Trip1
Type: discrete_state
Measures: module_board
---- Saw sensor: node23(3.1).CPU1 Internal E
Type: discrete_state
Measures: module_board
---- Saw sensor: node23(3.1).CPU2 Vcore
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23(3.1).CPU Temp 4
Type: threshold
Measures: temperature
Expressed in: C
---- Saw sensor: node23(3.1).CPU Temp 3
Type: threshold
Measures: temperature
Expressed in: C
**** Finished enumerating sensors on entity [Unknown] node23(3.1)
-- Saw entity [Unknown] node23(7.0) (Present)
---- Saw sensor: node23(7.0).Fan8
Type: threshold
Measures: fan
Expressed in: RPM
---- Saw sensor: node23(7.0).Fan7
Type: threshold
Measures: fan
Expressed in: RPM
---- Saw sensor: node23(7.0).Fan6
Type: threshold
Measures: fan
Expressed in: RPM
---- Saw sensor: node23(7.0).Fan5
Type: threshold
Measures: fan
Expressed in: RPM
---- Saw sensor: node23(7.0).Fan4
Type: threshold
Measures: fan
Expressed in: RPM
---- Saw sensor: node23(7.0).Fan3
Type: threshold
Measures: fan
Expressed in: RPM
---- Saw sensor: node23(7.0).Fan2
Type: threshold
Measures: fan
Expressed in: RPM
---- Saw sensor: node23(7.0).Fan1
Type: threshold
Measures: fan
Expressed in: RPM
---- Saw sensor: node23(7.0).VBAT
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23(7.0).5VSB
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23(7.0).1.5V
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23(7.0).12V
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23(7.0).5V
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23(7.0).3.3V
Type: threshold
Measures: voltage
Expressed in: volts
---- Saw sensor: node23(7.0).Sys Temp
Type: threshold
Measures: temperature
Expressed in: C
**** Finished enumerating sensors on entity [Unknown] node23(7.0)
-- Saw entity [Unknown] node23(10.0) (Present)
---- Saw sensor: node23(10.0).Power Supply
Type: discrete_state
Measures: power_supply
**** Finished enumerating sensors on entity [Unknown] node23(10.0)
-- Saw entity [Unknown] node23(23.1) (Present)
**** Finished enumerating sensors on entity [Unknown] node23(23.1)
** Finished enumerating entities on domain node23
Sensor node23(3.0).CPU1 Vcore value: 1.82 [Raw: 227]
Sensor node23(3.0).CPU Temp 2 value: 22.0 [Raw: 22]
Sensor node23(3.0).CPU Temp 1 value: 27.0 [Raw: 27]
Sensor node23(3.1).CPU2 Vcore value: 0.90 [Raw: 113]
Sensor node23(3.1).CPU Temp 4 value: -102.0 [Raw: 154]
Sensor node23(3.1).CPU Temp 3 value: 47.0 [Raw: 47]
Sensor node23(7.0).Fan8 value: 0 [Raw: 0]
Sensor node23(7.0).Fan7 value: 9600 [Raw: 96]
Sensor node23(7.0).Fan6 value: 9500 [Raw: 95]
Sensor node23(7.0).Fan5 value: 0 [Raw: 0]
Sensor node23(7.0).Fan4 value: 9600 [Raw: 96]
Sensor node23(7.0).Fan3 value: 9700 [Raw: 97]
Sensor node23(7.0).Fan2 value: 19200 [Raw: 192]
Sensor node23(7.0).Fan1 value: 20100 [Raw: 201]
Sensor node23(7.0).VBAT value: 1.94 [Raw: 121]
Sensor node23(7.0).5VSB value: 4.75 [Raw: 198]
Sensor node23(7.0).1.5V value: 3.30 [Raw: 206]
Sensor node23(7.0).12V value: 19.87 [Raw: 207]
Sensor node23(7.0).5V value: 3.34 [Raw: 139]
Sensor node23(7.0).3.3V value: 1.39 [Raw: 87]
Sensor node23(7.0).Sys Temp value: -102.0 [Raw: 154]
--
Eric J. Bowersox, Software Engineer Aspen Systems, Inc.
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> 3900 Youngfield Street
Tel: +01 303 431 4606 x113 Wheat Ridge, CO 80033, USA
Fax: +01 303 431 7196 <http://www.aspsys.com>
signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part
------------------------------------------------------------------------- This SF.Net email is sponsored by the Moblin Your Move Developer's challenge Build the coolest Linux based applications with Moblin SDK & win great prizes Grand prize is a trip for two to an Open Source event anywhere in the world http://moblin-contest.org/redirect.php?banner_id=100&url=/
_______________________________________________ Openipmi-developer mailing list [email protected] https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/openipmi-developer
