I'm seeing a problem when doing an administrative shutdown on an SG with dynamically created CSIs.
I'm assuming that dynamically creating CSIs is supported... I have an N+1 service group with one component entirely in the imm.xml config file including CSIs. There is another component in this SG with all its config in the imm.xml except the SaAmfCSI description. These are added dynamically after the system is up and running. Adding these CSIs dynamically seems to be working OK. The active and standby assignments are given. I can administratively shutdown the active SU, and failover occurs properly, etc. The problem comes when I try to admin shutdown the SG. All the active components are correctly handled, but the standby fails. I see this in the log for the standby SU: Apr 4 21:16:57 linux osafamfnd[4542]: NO Removing 'all (5) SIs' from 'safSu=DDD-SU1,safSg=DDD-Np1,safApp=DDDApp' Apr 4 21:16:57 linux osafamfnd[4542]: NO Removing 'safSi=DDD-Np1-SI-1,safApp=DDDApp' from 'safSu=DDD-SU1,safSg=DDD-Np1,safApp=DDDApp' Apr 4 21:16:57 linux osafamfnd[4542]: NO Removing 'safSi=DDD-Np1-SI-2,safApp=DDDApp' from 'safSu=DDD-SU1,safSg=DDD-Np1,safApp=DDDApp' Apr 4 21:16:57 linux osafamfnd[4542]: NO Removing 'safSi=DDD-Np1-SI-3,safApp=DDDApp' from 'safSu=DDD-SU1,safSg=DDD-Np1,safApp=DDDApp' Apr 4 21:16:57 linux osafamfnd[4542]: NO Removing 'safSi=DDD-Np1-SI-4,safApp=DDDApp' from 'safSu=DDD-SU1,safSg=DDD-Np1,safApp=DDDApp' Apr 4 21:16:57 linux osafamfnd[4542]: NO Removing 'safSi=DDD-Np1-SI-5,safApp=DDDApp' from 'safSu=DDD-SU1,safSg=DDD-Np1,safApp=DDDApp' But, I never see "Removed". It looks like it never finishes. Then any other admin operation on this SG results in: Apr 4 21:19:58 linux osafamfd[4761]: WA SG not in STABLE state (safSg=DDD-Np1,safApp=DDDApp) After doing the admin shutdown the SaAmfCSIAssignment entries for the standby SU that failed still exist in IMM. All other SaAmfCSIAssignment entries for the active SUs have been deleted, and I see this in the osafamfd log on the active controller. I never see deletes for the standby. Apr 4 21:16:57.143902 osafamfd [4761:avd_csi.c:1042] TR Deleting safCSIComp=safComp=DddManager\,safSu=DDD-SU5\,safSg=DDD-Np1\,safApp=DDDApp,safCsi=DddManager,safSi=DDD-Np1-SI-4,safApp=DDDApp It seems like it's a problem with the standby SU. I know that the components are getting the csiRemove callback, so it doesn't seem to be a component issue. I'll continue looking into this, but any help would be appreciated. Thanks! Alex ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ _______________________________________________ Opensaf-devel mailing list Opensaf-devel@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/opensaf-devel
