On Dec 9, 2009, at 2:09 PM, Gary Winiger wrote: >> Improving ACL fabrication and making it do a better job of >> approximating >> NFSv4 ACL, will still have the following problem: >> >>>> >>>> - The user could retrieve the fabricated ACL on the client and >>>> attempt >>>> to perform some operation only to be denied when the "real" ACL is >>>> evaluated on the server. > > This was my compelling reason for not doing my normal, I hate > configuration options, please fix it so ACL fabrication works. > IMO, it can't be reasonably fixed because ACL/ACE are different. > That's something we/the ARC accepted in the ZFS and NFSv4 cases.
After thinking about it some more, I reluctantly agree. +1 to the case. -- Glenn