We (Akamai) had a bad session compare function at one point; the compare was fixed, but also added this change to protect the LHASH.
So, yes, this can only really happen if one has a bad comparison function. -- -Todd Short // tsh...@akamai.com // Sent from my iPhone // "One if by land, two if by sea, three if by the Internet." > On May 31, 2015, at 4:22 PM, Richard Levitte via RT <r...@openssl.org> wrote: > > I'm not sure how that can happen, as each SSL_SESSION in that lhash will have > unique content. This is assured by the way lh_insert functions and by > ssl_session_cmp (which gets called by getrn in lhash.c, via the function > pointer cf). > > So while your suggestion will most probably work as a band aid, I'm thinking > you've really found a bug in ssl_session_cmp or in the lhash code itself. > Could > you verify? > >> On Sun May 31 21:24:04 2015, tsh...@akamai.com wrote: >> No, >> >> The second code sample removes a matching instance, but not >> necessarily the same instance. If they are not the same instance, then >> it would need to be re-inserted in and else clause. >> >> This is a fine distinction. >> >> This would leave to having the list and hash not contain the same >> contents: Either the number of items is different, or the two sets of >> items are different. >> >> There's a similar example in the code, I believe, but I'd have to >> search for it. >> >> -- >> -Todd Short >> // tsh...@akamai.com >> // Sent from my iPhone >> // "One if by land, two if by sea, three if by the Internet." >> >> >>>> On May 31, 2015, at 12:43 PM, Richard Levitte via RT >>> <r...@openssl.org> wrote: >>> >>> You solution does the following: >>> >>> if (lh_SSL_SESSION_retrieve(p->cache, s) == s) { >>> (void)lh_SSL_SESSION_delete(p->cache, s); >>> ... >>> >>> Would you agree that the following does the same? >>> >>> if (lh_SSL_SESSION_delete(p->cache, s) == s) { >>> ... >>> >>> >>>> On Sat May 30 09:48:06 2015, tsh...@akamai.com wrote: >>>> Hello OpenSSL Org: >>>> >>>> This is a change that Akamai has made to its >>>> implementation of OpenSSL. >>>> >>>> Version: master branch >>>> Description: >>>> lh_SSL_SESSION_delete() not checked >>>> >>>> Fix an OpenSSL issue where the >>>> return code of lh_SSL_SESSION_delete() >>>> is not checked, causing a >>>> stale reference in the lhash. >>>> >>>> Github link: > https://github.com/akamai/openssl/commit/3a114c2f0e3bf241732fef7a2d339a230ca68abc >>>> And attachment. >>>> >>>> Thank you. >>>> -- >>>> -Todd Short >>>> // tsh...@akamai.com >>>> // “One if by land, two if by sea, three if by the Internet.” >>> >>> >>> -- >>> Richard Levitte >>> levi...@openssl.org > > > -- > Richard Levitte > levi...@openssl.org > _______________________________________________ openssl-dev mailing list To unsubscribe: https://mta.openssl.org/mailman/listinfo/openssl-dev